For fixed terminal time and fixed endpoint, use the maximizing form of the Pontryagin maximum principle. For dynamics and running cost , there are multipliers , not all zero, with , and Hamiltonian of an optimal-control problem . Along an optimum, , , and the chosen control maximizes over admissible controls almost everywhere. Fixed terminal state imposes no prescribed terminal value of ; fixed time imposes no free-time condition . The normal case scales ; abnormal extremals have .
For this problem the normal Hamiltonian of an optimal-control problem is
Maximization gives , . The costate equations give , , hence , . Nonzero velocities rotate at constant angular rate, and rotational symmetry permits , . For a closed path, , with integer . Then , so the required positive endpoint has , and cost .
To prove a global minimum rather than only classify stationary extremals, write and subtract its time average; this changes neither its derivative nor . The resulting closed mean-zero path satisfies the periodic Wirtinger inequality . This follows immediately by its Fourier expansion: each nonzero mode of the derivative has squared multiplier at least . The Cauchy-Schwarz inequality now gives
The argument extends to square-integrable controls by the periodic Sobolev/Fourier interpretation. Thus the cost is at least for every feasible control. Equality is attained by
These satisfy every endpoint and have cost . Therefore the minimum is , an area-constrained quadratic control cost. The global inequality also prevents an overlooked abnormal candidate from lowering it; in fact an abnormal finite maximizing Hamiltonian of an optimal-control problem would force both linear control coefficients to vanish and then force zero velocity, incompatible with .