Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2007 iii Paper 7 4 i Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
First determine when a group automorphism can carry a transposition to another type of involution. An involution in is a product of disjoint transpositions, and its conjugacy class has sizeAn automorphism preserves element orders and conjugacy-class sizes. Equality with the transposition-class size requiresFor this says , which has no integral solution . For , the minimum value of the left side, at , is ; it increases strictly for larger . For , even its minimum exceeds : at this is , and the ratio of these two quantities increases at the next step by . Thus only in degree six can the transposition class be exchanged with a different involution class, namely the triple transpositions.
We next prove that any automorphism preserving transpositions is an inner automorphism. Regard a transposition as an edge of the complete graph on the letters. Two distinct transpositions fail to commute exactly when their edges meet. Any family of pairwise intersecting edges is contained in a vertex star or a triangle: after choosing and , an edge not containing must be , which precludes any fourth edge. For , the stars are therefore distinguished as the maximal such families of size . An automorphism permutes stars, inducing a permutation of the letters; their pairwise intersections show that is sent to . Since transpositions generate , this is conjugation by a permutation.
For , stars and triangles both have three edges, but a star generates while a triangle generates a subgroup . An automorphism preserves the order of the generated subgroup and hence still distinguishes stars. For , every permutation of the three transpositions is induced by conjugation in , since its conjugation action on them is faithful and has order six. The groups have trivial automorphism groups. This completes the small cases.
It follows that all automorphisms for are inner. In degree six, an automorphism permutes the two involution classes of size 15; the kernel of this action consists precisely of the inner automorphisms. Therefore the automorphisms of the symmetric group satisfy