Suppose has degree one. For degree-one classes on the target, naturality of the cup product and the definition of the degree of a map between oriented manifolds give
If a nonzero had , nondegeneracy of the Poincare duality pairing would supply with nonzero right side, a contradiction. Thus injects the -dimensional real degree-one cohomology into the -dimensional source. Hence . This is the cohomological injectivity of a degree-one map in this setting.
Conversely, for , express as . Collapse the second punctured summand and the joining circle to a point. The quotient of the retained punctured summand by its boundary is homeomorphic to , giving a continuous map to that surface. Its restriction to a small oriented disc away from the collapsing region is an orientation-preserving homeomorphism, and a point in this disc has exactly one preimage. The induced map on local top homology, and hence on the fundamental class, has coefficient . The map therefore has degree one. For , the same construction is the familiar collapse of the complement of a disc to obtain .
Consequently
This proves both directions of the degree-one maps between closed oriented surfaces criterion. The case also admits the identity map.