Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 7 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
First we prove the Krein-Milman theorem in the required setting. If is empty the conclusion is immediate, so assume it is nonempty. A face of a convex set is a convex subset with the property that an interior point of a segment in belongs to only if both endpoints do. Consider all nonempty weakly compact faces of , ordered by reverse inclusion. A chain has a nonempty intersection by compactness and the finite intersection property; that intersection is again a compact face. The Zorn lemma gives a minimal compact face .
If contained distinct points, a bounded linear functional separating them would be nonconstant on . Its maximizer set is a nonempty proper compact face of , hence a face of , contradicting minimality. Therefore is a singleton and its member is an extreme point of . The same reasoning applies to each nonempty compact face of , so each such face contains an extreme point of .
Let be the norm-closed convex hull of the extreme points of . A weakly compact subset of a Banach space is weakly closed, hence norm closed, so . If , the Hahn-Banach separation theorem gives with . The maximizer face of on contains an extreme point of . Then , contradicting . We concludeNorm and weak closed convex hulls coincide by the same separation theorem. The printed phrase “closed convex cover” is understood in this standard closed-convex-hull sense.
Now work in the real space of continuous functions on a compact space on the Cantor set. The extreme points of a real continuous-function unit ball are exactly the continuous sign functions:If , continuity supplies a neighbourhood where . The Cantor cylinder sets form a clopen base, so choose a nonempty cylinder inside that neighbourhood. Its indicator function is continuous, and are distinct members of with midpoint . Hence is not extreme. Conversely, if is pointwise sign-valued and with , equality at the endpoint of the scalar interval forces at every point.
To prove the closed-hull assertion without assuming weak compactness, take and . A sufficiently fine finite partition of into Cantor cylinders has oscillation of less than on each cell, by uniform continuity. Choose a value on each cell and let be the corresponding continuous step function. Then . For each sign vector , let take value on cell , and assign the weightThese weights are nonnegative, sum to one, and satisfy . Thus is a convex combination of extreme points. This is clopen sign approximation in the real Cantor unit ball, provingNevertheless is not weakly compact. The suggested functions lie in and converge pointwise to the function equal to zero at and one at every other point of . It is discontinuous at zero, since tends to zero. If were weakly compact, the sequence, viewed as a net, would have a weakly convergent subnet with limit in . Point evaluations are bounded linear functionals, so that subnet would have the same pointwise limit; its indices are cofinal in the original sequence. The limit would therefore be the discontinuous function just described, a contradiction. This discontinuous pointwise limit obstruction to weak compactness gives the required failure of weak compactness, despite the closed-hull equality.