Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2022 ii Paper 4 11I b ii Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-09-25
Let and formFor sufficiently large , every factor is positive and at most . Every odd prime divisor of makes a quadratic residue modulo , so part (a) gives or .
For an odd prime power , the congruence has at most two residue classes, because each root modulo is simple and lifts uniquely. ThereforeSince for odd ,The prime contributes at most , because . Ifthen, for all sufficiently large , and hence
On the other hand, the product contains at least factors for large , and every one satisfiesonce is sufficiently large. ThusComparing the two estimates givesfor every sufficiently large . This is the elementary logarithmic lower bound for primes in the quadratic-residue classes of two.