Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2020 ii Paper 3 21I d Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-09-29
Write . We first prove that is dense. Otherwise some nonzero lies in its orthogonal complement, soBy part (b), choose finite-dimensional spaces containing such that in operator norm. Sincethe operator is not injective. Therefore is not surjective; the contrapositive of part (c) makes an eigenvalue of . Choose unit vectors with . ThenCompactness gives a subsequence for which converges. Since , the displayed relation makes converge to a unit vector , and continuity gives , contradicting the hypothesis. Thus is dense.
Next suppose were not bounded below, or equivalently that its lower norm were zero. There would be unit vectors with , henceAgain a convergent subsequence of forces the corresponding to converge to a unit vector satisfying , another contradiction. Therefore some satisfies
This lower bound makes closed: if converges, then is Cauchy and its limit maps to the same limit. Since the image is both dense and closed, it is all of . We have proved the Fredholm alternative for a compact operator: every nonzero spectral value of a compact operator is an eigenvalue.