Magnetic subcriticality of a razor-thin disk Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-11-05
Magnetic subcriticality refers to a mass-to-flux ratio below its critical mass-to-flux ratio. For an idealized thin layer threaded by a uniform frozen-in perpendicular magnetic field, define in SI unitsHere is the surface density and the perpendicular magnetic field. The magnetically subcritical case has , or . In the specified ideal layer, magnetic support prevents the linear gravitational collapse studied by Takenori Nakano and Takashi Nakamura. Their original Gaussian-unit threshold is . The numerical coefficient is tied to geometry and field assumptions.[ref]
Gravitational Instability of Magnetized Gaseous Disks by Takenori Nakano and Takashi Nakamura. Original abstract, perpendicular frozen-in field and critical column-density-to-field ratio
A complementary sufficient-contraction result applies to an isolated cold initially resting razor-thin disk. If pointwise, the absolute gravity-equivalent magnetic surface density is smaller than the actual surface density. The positive-kernel comparison of thin-disk fields then makes the integrand in the horizontal virial balance of a cold magnetized fluid negative above and below the disk. Its radial second moment therefore begins to decrease. This weak-field inequality is on the magnetically supercritical disk side of the mass-to-flux convention.
The second-moment conclusion is global. It does not establish inward acceleration of every fluid element, and it does not prove unlimited subsequent collapse. Pressure, rotation, magnetic flux loss and different boundary-field configurations require their own analysis.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2014 iii Paper 54 2 d Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
Integrate Poisson equation for Newtonian gravity through a narrow slab around the disk. The horizontal derivative contributions vanish as its thickness tends to zero, leaving the normal-derivative jumpThe even function symmetry of makes the derivatives opposite, soIn the current-free simply connected upper half-space, Ampère's circuital law gives and permits a magnetic scalar potential. Rescale it so that . The divergence-free condition makes satisfy Laplace's equation, withCompare with the gravitational jump condition. Subject to the same isolated-field boundary condition at infinity, is the harmonic potential of the effective surface densityThis gravity-equivalent magnetic surface density can have either sign; it is a mathematical representation of the exterior magnetic field, not physical negative mass. An imposed nondecaying field would require additional boundary data and would not be fixed by the disk surface density alone.
Positive-kernel comparison of thin-disk fields Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-11-05
The vertical field of a disk has kernel . The triangle inequality therefore bounds a signed-surface density field by the field of its absolute surface density. If that surface density is everywhere smaller than a nonnegative comparison surface density, their vertical fields satisfy the displayed strict comparison, provided the integrals exist and the strict bound holds on positive measure. This is useful when comparing gravity-equivalent magnetic surface density with actual disk mass.