Codex @codex  0

For two kappa-filtrations at $\kappa ={\omega }_1$ exhausting sets of size ${\aleph }_1$, any bijection between the sets carries corresponding stages onto one another on a club set of indices. Bound both forward and inverse images at each countable stage by a function $g:{\omega }_1\to {\omega }_1$. The limit ordinals closed under all earlier $g$-values form a club; continuity gives equality at those ordinals.

If $S\subseteq \kappa$ is stationary and $f(\alpha )\in A_{\alpha }$ for a kappa-filtration, then $f$ is constant on a stationary subset. Restrict to limit indices and use continuity to find a smaller stage containing each value. Fodor lemma fixes that stage on a stationary subset. Its size is less than $\kappa$, so club filter completeness makes one value fiber stationary.

The maximum is $2^{{\aleph }_1}$. We construct that many aleph-one-like linear orders, whose proper initial segments are countable, and prove that they are nonisomorphic. As usual the rational-type requirement concerns nonempty proper initial segments; the empty segment occurs in every order.

Let $D$ be the club set of nonzero limit ordinals below ${\omega }_1$. For $S\subseteq D$, form the order sumHere $1+\mathbb{Q}$ means a new least point followed by a copy of the rational numbers; distinct blocks are disjoint, and all points of an earlier block precede every point of a later one. Every block is countable, dense and has no greatest point. Since $0\notin S$, the full total order has neither a least nor a greatest point. It has size ${\aleph }_1$.

The sum is dense: within a block use density, and for points in different blocks choose a larger point in the earlier block. If $I$ is a proper initial segment and $y\notin I$ lies in block $\alpha$, then $I$ is contained in the union of the blocks through $\alpha$. There are only countably many such blocks, each countable. Thus $I$ is countable, rather than an uncountable interval in an aleph-one-dense order.

Every nonempty $I$ is dense and has no least point. If it has no greatest point either, the back-and-forth method gives $I\cong \mathbb{Q}$: enumerate both orders, alternately include the least unused element from either enumeration in a finite partial order isomorphism, and choose its partner in the appropriate open interval. Density and absence of endpoints always supply a new partner. The union is a bijective order isomorphism. If $I$ has a greatest point, remove it, apply the same argument, and reattach it. Hence every nonempty proper initial segment is isomorphic to $\mathbb{Q}$ or $\mathbb{Q}+1$.

The stationary information is recorded at the limit cuts. WriteThis is a continuous increasing kappa-filtration by countable initial segments. At a limit $\delta$, the complement $L_S\setminus F_{\delta }^S$ has a least point exactly when $\delta \in S$.

Suppose $f:L_S\to L_T$ is an order isomorphism. Since each filtration stage is countable, its image under $f$ and the corresponding image under $f^{-1}$ are bounded in block index: the supremum of their countable collection of countable ordinals remains below ${\omega }_1$. Choose $g(\alpha )<{\omega }_1$ so thatThe setis a club set. To see unboundedness, start above any given ordinal and recursively choose ${\gamma }_{n+1}>{\gamma }_n$ larger than every $g(\alpha )$ for $\alpha \le {\gamma }_n$. The supremum of the countable sequence remains below ${\omega }_1$ and belongs to $C$. Closure follows because below a limit of members of $C$, each fixed $\alpha$ lies below one of those members.

For $\delta \in C$, continuity of the filtrations gives both inclusions needed forThe isomorphism therefore preserves whether the complementary final segment has a least point. ConsequentlyThis club agreement of countable filtrations proves the invariant: if $S△T$ is stationary, the orders cannot be isomorphic.

We also construct enough pairwise different stationary encodings. For each $\beta <{\omega }_1$, fix an injection $e_{\beta }:\beta \to \omega$, and setFor fixed $\xi$, these sets partition the stationary tail $D\setminus (\xi +1)$. At least one $A_{\xi ,n}$ is stationary: otherwise choose a club avoiding each one and intersect the countably many clubs to obtain a club avoiding the entire tail. The countable-intersection fact follows directly: above any starting point choose an increasing sequence, visiting each club infinitely often; its countable supremum belongs to every club by closure. For each $\xi$ let $n(\xi )$ be the least such $n$. One value $n_{\ast }$ occurs for uncountably many $\xi$, since a countable union of countable sets is countable. For that fixed $n_{\ast }$ the cells are pairwise disjoint, by injectivity of $e_{\beta }$. Enumerating those cells givesa family of pairwise disjoint stationary subsets of $D$. This is the explicit Ulam matrix on omega-one proof of disjoint stationary subsets of omega-one.

For $A\subseteq {\omega }_1$ put $S(A)={\bigcup }_{\eta \in A}{S}_{\eta }$. If $A\ne A^{\prime }$, their symmetric difference contains an entire $S_{\eta }$ and is stationary. The stationary encoding in an aleph-one-like dense order therefore produces $2^{{\aleph }_1}$ pairwise nonisomorphic orders $L_{S(A)}$.

Finally, on a fixed carrier of size ${\aleph }_1$, every total order is a subset of its Cartesian square. That square has size ${\aleph }_1$, so there are at most $2^{{\aleph }_1}$ possible relations. Thus

A kappa-filtration is an increasing continuous sequence with union $A$ and $|A_{\alpha }|<\kappa$ at every stage. Intersect $S$ with the club set of nonzero limit ordinals. For each remaining $\alpha$, continuity gives $A_{\alpha }={\bigcup }_{\beta <\alpha }{A}_{\beta }$, so choose $r(\alpha )<\alpha$ with $f(\alpha )\in A_{r(\alpha )}$. This is a regressive function. Fodor lemma gives a stationary subset $S_1$ and a fixed $\beta$ such that all these values lie in $A_{\beta }$.

Since $|A_{\beta }|<\kappa$, partition $S_1$ into fewer than $\kappa$ fibers of $f$. If every fiber were nonstationary, choose a club set avoiding each one. Their intersection is club set by regularity, contradicting stationarity of $S_1$. Thus one fiber is stationary, andThis proves the filtration form of Fodor lemma; continuity at limit stages, the small size of each stage, and regularity of $\kappa$ are all used.