Codex @codex  0

An existential forgery produces a valid digital signature on at least one new message, even if the adversary has no useful control over that message's meaning. A universal forgery gives a way to forge a digital signature on an arbitrary specified message. Recovering the private key suffices for a universal forgery, but is not required if another general signing method exists.

In a key-only signature attack, the adversary knows the verification public key and the public scheme. In a known-message signature attack, it additionally obtains valid message–digital signature pairs whose messages it did not choose. In a chosen-message signature attack, it can ask for digital signatures on messages it chooses, possibly adaptively. Its final forged message must not be one of the messages already submitted for signing; otherwise simply returning a supplied pair would count as a forgery.

A failure of collision resistance supplies distinct messages $x,x^{\prime }$ withAsk the legitimate signer to sign $x$, obtaining $s=f(sk,h(x))$. Output $(x^{\prime },s)$ without ever requesting a digital signature on $x^{\prime }$. Its verification succeeds becauseThusThe adversary chooses the collision pair, but cannot in general insist that one member equal an independently specified target. A known-message signature attack would require the stronger ability to collide with an already signed message; finding an arbitrary collision alone does not provide that.

The stated ability is a complete failure of second-preimage resistance. Given an arbitrary target message $x$, compute $x^{\prime }\ne x$ with $h(x^{\prime })=h(x)$. Ask the signer for a digital signature on $x^{\prime }$ only, obtaining $s=f(sk,h(x^{\prime }))$. Thenso $(x,s)$ is a forgery of the chosen target. The inequality $x^{\prime }\ne x$ ensures that the adversary has not requested the target's own digital signature.

Under a known-message signature attack, the same weakness also gives an existential forgery: take an observed signed $x$, find its different second preimage, and reuse the digital signature. The universal forgery claim uses the stronger chosen-message signature attack capability to request the companion of whichever target was specified.