Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2010 iii Paper 12 1 ii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
The printed assertion is false when maximal means largest in the natural-number labelling. Both the original PDF and the TeX have this wording. The specified operation gives the complete graph, not the Rado graph.
Fix any two distinct vertices , and choose . Apply the hypergraph extension property of to , prescribing that the pair extend to a hyperedge; prescribe all other pairs in arbitrarily. The resulting witness has , so is a hyperedge whose largest vertex is . Deleting that vertex produces the edge in .
Since were arbitrary,The Rado graph has nonedges: its hypergraph extension property supplies a new vertex nonadjacent to any specified existing vertex. Therefore and cannot be isomorphic graphs. This argument holds for every representative of the universal three-uniform structure labelled by , so changing its labelling does not repair the assertion. Equivalently, in an independently sampled representative each pair has infinitely many larger vertices that complete it to a triple, almost surely.
A valid related construction is to fix a vertex and take its link hypergraph: make an edge exactly when is a hyperedge, on the remaining vertex set. This is indeed the Rado graph. To prove it, take any disjoint finite sets of vertices other than , put , and prescribe triples through the pairs for and no triples through for . Complete all other pair prescriptions arbitrarily. The hypergraph extension property produces a new vertex adjacent in the link to all of and none of . Uniqueness from part (i), for , now proves the claimed hypergraph isomorphism for this corrected operation.