Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2001 iii Paper 3 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
A soluble group is one whose derived series terminates: , , and for some finite . Each factor of this series is abelian. Conversely, if a subnormal series has abelian factors, repeated commutation moves down the series, so the derived series terminates. This explains the usual alternative definition in terms of abelian factors. The least is the derived length.
Subgroups are soluble because ; quotients are soluble because a group homomorphism maps a derived subgroup onto the derived subgroup of its image. Solubility is also closed under extensions: if has derived length at most and has length at most , then and . Abelian and nilpotent groups are soluble; has derived subgroup and derived length two. In a finite group, solubility is equivalent to every composition factor being cyclic of prime order: simple soluble groups are abelian and therefore cyclic of prime order, while a composition series with these factors builds a soluble group by extensions. This need not give an ambient-normal series with cyclic prime-order factors, which is the stronger property of supersolubility.
A Hall subgroup for a prime set is a subgroup whose order uses only primes in and whose index uses only primes outside . Its order is the full -part of . Sylow's theorem is the singleton-prime case; solubility allows all prime sets, although Hall subgroups need not be normal, as the order-two subgroups of show.
Prove Hall subgroup existence in soluble groups by induction on . The trivial group is immediate. Choose a nontrivial minimal normal subgroup . It is elementary abelian of some prime characteristic : is characteristic in and normal in , so minimality and solubility force . A nontrivial Sylow subgroup of this finite abelian group is characteristic, making a p-group. The subgroup of pth powers is characteristic and proper, so minimality makes it trivial. This proves minimal normal subgroups of finite solvable groups are elementary abelian.
By induction has a Hall -subgroup . Let be its inverse image. Then is a -number. If , the whole is a -group and is the desired Hall subgroup. If , has order prime to . We now prove the required complement existence explicitly, rather than invoking a splitting theorem as a substitute.
Write additively as an -vector space. Choose representatives for with . Conjugation gives a well-defined action of on , because changing a representative by an element of the abelian group does not change that action. Define by . Associativity yieldsSince is invertible in , set . Sum the identity over and use the bijection to obtainChanging representatives to removes the multiplication error:Thus is a homomorphic section. Its image has order , intersects trivially, and complements in . This is coprime splitting over an elementary abelian normal subgroup. Finally is a -number and is a -number, soOnly existence was needed here; the fuller Hall theorem also gives conjugacy and containment of arbitrary -subgroups. Solubility makes the elementary-abelian minimal-normal induction possible and cannot simply be omitted.