Write the unknown common eigenbasis as an unknown unit Bloch vector . Then has vector , while has vector . A single deterministic channel working for every possible basis must therefore map to for every unit .
By the basis-independent conversion of qubit Bloch radii, linearity forces that channel to be . Explicitly, add the conditions for and to get , then use the three coordinate directions to fix its action on every Pauli matrix. But , so part iv excludes complete positivity. Thus the forward conversion cannot be implemented reliably without knowing the basis.
The reverse conversion would require , which is not even positive by part ii. Therefore the reverse conversion is also impossible. Unitary operations interspersed with physically allowed depolarizing maps cannot evade these restrictions: their composition remains a physical quantum channel. The question concerns one basis-independent operation on the supplied qubit, not an additional resource of many copies for learning its basis.