= Solution
The measurable structure of an <exchange economy> includes measurability of consumers' <preference relations>: in particular, for each rational vector $q$, the set
$$
E_q=\{a:f(a)+q\in\mathbb R_+^L,\ f(a)+q\succ_a f(a)\}
$$
is measurable. Continuity of each individual's <preference relation> alone would not imply this across-consumer requirement. We use this usual measurability convention explicitly.
There are only countably many vectors in $\mathbb Q^L$. Remove all the null sets $E_q$ that have zero measure, obtaining
$$
D=A\setminus\bigcup_{\mu(E_q)=0}E_q,\qquad\mu(D)=1.
$$
Let $V=\{q\in\mathbb Q^L:\mu(E_q)>0\}$. Equivalently, $V$ is the union over $a\in D$ of the rational strict-improvement directions available to consumer $a$. This choice of $D$ ensures that a direction available to even one consumer in $D$ is available to a positive-measure group.
We claim that $0\notin\operatorname{co}V$. Otherwise, take finitely many $q_1,\ldots,q_m\in V$ and positive weights $\lambda_i$ with $\sum_i\lambda_i=1$ and $\sum_i\lambda_iq_i=0$. Choose $t>0$ so small that $2t<\min_i\mu(E_{q_i})$. We can choose disjoint measurable sets $F_i\subseteq E_{q_i}$ with $\mu(F_i)=t\lambda_i$. Indeed, after the earlier choices remove at most $t$ mass, the remaining portion of $E_{q_i}$ has mass greater than $t$. The scalar case of the <Lyapunov convexity theorem>, applied to its restricted <atomless measure>, realizes every mass between zero and its total, including $t\lambda_i$.
Now change $f(a)$ to $f(a)+q_i$ on $F_i$ and leave it unchanged elsewhere. Every changed bundle is a feasible consumption bundle and is strictly preferred by its recipient. This new <consumption allocation> $g$ remains integrable, and
$$
\int_A(g-f)\,d\mu=\sum_i\mu(F_i)q_i=t\sum_i\lambda_iq_i=0.
$$
Thus $g$ is exactly feasible and improves a group of total mass $t>0$, contradicting <Pareto efficiency>. Notice that no individual's consumption bundles were averaged: an <atomless measure> allows different small cohorts to make different improvements. Individual convexity of the <preference relations> is unnecessary.
If $V$ is nonempty, separate its <convex hull> from zero using the <supporting hyperplane theorem>. There exists $p\ne0$ with $p\cdot q\geq0$ for every $q\in V$. Only weak separation is needed, so it is harmless if zero belongs to the closure of this <convex hull>.
Fix any $a\in D$ and any $y\succ_a f(a)$. Completeness and continuity make the strictly preferred set relatively open in $\mathbb R_+^L$. Approximate $y-f(a)$ by rational vectors $q_n$ for which $f(a)+q_n$ is feasible and still strictly preferred. At a zero consumption coordinate, choose the rational approximations from the feasible side. Then $a\in E_{q_n}$ implies $q_n\in V$, and passage to the limit gives $p\cdot(y-f(a))\geq0$. The same full-measure set $D$ works for all such bundles $y$, not merely for each bundle separately.
If $V$ is empty, the same rational approximation argument says that consumers in $D$ have no strictly preferred feasible bundles at all. In that case any nonzero $p$ satisfies the required implication. In either case,
$$
\boxed{(f,p)\text{ is a price quasi-equilibrium with transfers for some }p\ne0.}
$$
To see why transfers cannot simply be omitted, give all consumers endowment $(1,1)$ and <utility function> $u(x_1,x_2)=x_1+x_2$. Allocate $(3/2,3/2)$ to half of them and $(1/2,1/2)$ to the other half. This is <Pareto efficient>, since any Pareto improvement would increase the integral of utility while aggregate resources fix it. At these interior bundles the support inequalities force $p_1=p_2>0$: directions arbitrarily close to $(1,-1)$ force equality, and strict increases force positivity. The poorer half then receives less wealth than the original endowment supplies and has a cheaper strict improvement within its original budget. The support theorem concerns the redistributed budget, as defined in part (b).
Back to article page