Solution (source code)

= Solution

In cylindrical coordinates the particle's radial and vertical equations are $\ddot r-r\dot\phi^2=-\Phi_r$ and $\ddot z=-\Phi_z$. Axisymmetry gives <conservation of angular momentum>, with <specific angular momentum> $h=r^2\dot\phi$. Eliminating the cyclic azimuthal motion therefore gives
$$
\ddot r=-\partial_r\left(\Phi+\frac{h^2}{2r^2}\right),\qquad\ddot z=-\partial_z\left(\Phi+\frac{h^2}{2r^2}\right).
$$
Thus \b[$\boxed{\Phi_1=\Phi+h^2/(2r^2)}$] governs the meridional motion. Its conserved energy is $\tfrac12(\dot r^2+\dot z^2)+\Phi_1$. The additional term is the <centrifugal barrier> appropriate to fixed angular momentum.

For a <point mass>, $\Phi=-GM/\sqrt{r^2+z^2}$. If $h\ne0$, the vertical derivative vanishes only at $z=0$, and the radial stationary condition there gives $r_0=h^2/(GM)$. This is the sole stationary point with $r>0$, at energy $-GM/(2r_0)$. Its <Hessian matrix> is
$$
\left.\nabla^2_{r,z}\Phi_1\right|_{(r_0,0)}=\frac{GM}{r_0^3}\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\0&1\end{pmatrix}.
$$
Consequently the local contours are closed, approximately circular curves about a strict minimum. Finite negative-energy contours above the minimum remain closed; the centrifugal barrier prevents approach to the axis and the negative energy prevents escape to infinity. The zero contour satisfies $z^2=4r^4/r_0^2-r^2$, while positive-energy contours can be unbounded. The left panel illustrates these features; portions of the outer contours extend outside the plotting window.

\Image[/past-exam-of-the-mathematics-course-of-the-university-of-cambridge/2004/iii/paper-68-effective-potentials.png]
{title=Meridional contours of fixed-angular-momentum and fixed-angular-velocity point-mass potentials}

Each panel uses its own circular radius as length unit and $GM/r_0$ as potential unit. Linearizing near the minimum gives
$$
\delta\ddot r=-\Omega_K^2\delta r,\qquad\delta\ddot z=-\Omega_K^2\delta z,\qquad\Omega_K^2=\frac{GM}{r_0^3}.
$$
The radial and <vertical epicyclic frequencies> both equal the circular orbital frequency. \b[Circular <Kepler orbits> are stable to small meridional perturbations of a freely moving particle.] With no dissipation the oscillations persist rather than decay. A change in h shifts the circular radius to a nearby orbit; azimuthal phase itself is neutral by rotational symmetry. If $h=0$, there is no stationary point or centrifugal barrier and this circular-orbit stability discussion does not apply.