= Solution
In <resistive-force theory>, the flagellum is slender and moves at a small <Reynolds number>, so local viscous resistance is linear in its <velocity> and fluid and body inertia are neglected. Normal and tangential resistance coefficients are treated as positive constants, usually $\kappa_N>\kappa_T$. The approximation neglects distant hydrodynamic interactions along the filament, head-tail interactions, nearby boundaries and self-contact. The centreline is an <inextensible filament> with prescribed shape. Its local resistance tensor is
$$
K=\kappa_T\mathbf t\mathbf t+\kappa_N(I-\mathbf t\mathbf t).
$$
Since the filament velocity relative to distant fluid is $-\mathbf w$, the fluid force on a filament element is $K\mathbf w\,ds$. The equal and opposite force on the fluid has total axial component $T$. Projecting onto $\mathbf i$ gives
$$
-T=\int_0^L\mathbf i\cdot K\mathbf w\,ds=(\kappa_T-\kappa_N)\int_0^L(\mathbf w\cdot\mathbf t)(\mathbf t\cdot\mathbf i)ds+\kappa_N\int_0^L\mathbf w\cdot\mathbf i\,ds.
$$
This establishes the thrust expression with its force-on-fluid convention.
For a uniform <travelling wave>, write the moving centreline as $\mathbf r(s,t)=\mathbf r_{\rm wave}(s-ct)+(V-U)t\mathbf i$, where $s$ is material <arc length> and $|\mathbf r_{\rm wave}'|=1$. Differentiating at fixed material label gives $\mathbf r_t=(V-U)\mathbf i-c\mathbf t$. Hence
$$
\boxed{\mathbf w=(U-V)\mathbf i+c\mathbf t.}
$$
Let $q=\mathbf t\cdot\mathbf i=X_s$, $\alpha=\langle q\rangle$ and $\beta=\langle q^2\rangle$, where these brackets are contour-length averages. The axial wavelength divided by contour wavelength is $\alpha=V/c$. For a filament comprising whole wave periods, or after the usual period averaging, $c\int_0^Lq\,ds=VL$. This averaging is needed to avoid end-phase corrections for an arbitrary fraction of a wavelength. Substitution of $\mathbf w$ into the thrust expression now gives
$$
T=(V-U)[(\kappa_T-\kappa_N)\beta L+\kappa_NL]-\kappa_TVL.
$$
For $\gamma=\kappa_T/\kappa_N$ and $r=1-\gamma$, this is $T/(\kappa_NL)=Vr(1-\beta)-U(1-r\beta)$. The swimming body is <force-free>, so the reaction thrust on the head-tail assembly balances its head drag. Thus $T=\delta\kappa_NLU$, and <linear resistive-force propulsion of a travelling filament> gives
$$
\boxed{U=V\frac{(1-\gamma)(1-\beta)}{1+\delta-(1-\gamma)\beta}.}
$$
We henceforth assume $0<\gamma<1$, $\delta\geq0$ and $0<\beta<1$. Isotropic resistance, $\gamma=1$, gives no propulsion in this model.
The flagellar contribution to <viscous dissipation> is the positive quadratic form $P_f=\int\mathbf w\cdot K\mathbf w\,ds$. Expanding it, and using $c\langle q\rangle=V$, gives
$$
P_f=\kappa_NL\left\{(V-U)^2[1-(1-\gamma)\beta]-2\gamma V(V-U)+\gamma c^2\right\}.
$$
There is also head dissipation $\delta\kappa_NLU^2$. Equivalently, the work of the flagellar deformation relative to the translating head is $P_f+UT$; the force balance makes $UT$ precisely the head dissipation. Consequently, with $\alpha=V/c$,
$$
\boxed{\frac{E}{\kappa_NLU^2}=\left(\frac VU-1\right)^2(\beta\gamma+1-\beta)-2\gamma\frac VU\left(\frac VU-1\right)+\frac{\gamma V^2}{\alpha^2U^2}+\delta.}
$$
This derives the rate of working, rather than merely inferring it from the thrust.
The <Cauchy-Schwarz inequality> gives $\alpha^2=\langle q\rangle^2\leq\langle q^2\rangle=\beta$. Equality requires $q$ to be constant almost everywhere. For a planar periodic filament this is an ideal sawtooth with alternating transverse tangent and fixed axial tangent, or a limit with negligibly rounded corners. It is not an identity for a general sinusoidal wave, and the ideal calculation omits the elastic cost of sharp corners.
For the stipulated equality $\alpha^2=\beta$, put $d=1+\delta$ and eliminate $V$ at fixed $U$ using $V/U=(d-r\beta)/[r(1-\beta)]$. Direct simplification yields
$$
F(\beta):=\frac{E}{\kappa_NLU^2}=\frac{(d-r\beta)(\gamma d+\delta r\beta)}{r^2\beta(1-\beta)}.
$$
The derivative is
$$
F'(\beta)=\frac{r(\delta^2-\gamma)\beta^2+2\gamma d^2\beta-\gamma d^2}{r^2\beta^2(1-\beta)^2}.
$$
Writing $A=r(\delta^2-\gamma)$ and $B=\gamma d^2$, the numerator is $A\beta^2+2B\beta-B$. It is negative at zero and equals $(\delta+\gamma)^2>0$ at one. Its derivative is positive throughout $(0,1)$: this is immediate if $A\geq0$; if $A<0$, its minimum derivative is $2(A+B)=2(\delta+\gamma)^2>0$. Since $F$ diverges at both endpoints, the unique stationary point is the global <fixed-speed energy optimum for a planar flagellum>:
$$
\boxed{\beta_* =\frac{B}{B+\sqrt{B^2+AB}},\qquad A=(1-\gamma)(\delta^2-\gamma),\quad B=\gamma(1+\delta)^2.}
$$
This form includes the case $A=0$, when $\beta_*=1/2$, without a removable division by zero. With no head drag it reduces to $\beta_*=1/(1+\sqrt\gamma)$.
\b[The printed final optimality formula does not follow from the preceding thrust and power equations.] For a concrete check, $\gamma=1/2$, $\delta=0$ gives $F=(2-\beta)/[\beta(1-\beta)]$. The derived minimum is at $\beta=2-\sqrt2$. The printed formula instead gives $\beta^2=\sqrt6-2$, hence $\beta\approx0.67044$, where $F'\ne0$ and the expenditure is greater. Thus the thrust and working formulas can both be established as above, but the last printed conclusion must be replaced by the derived optimum.
Back to article page