= Solution
For odd $p$, a <subgroup> $N$ is <powerfully embedded> in $G$ if $[N,G]\le N^p$, where $N^p=\langle n^p:n\in N\rangle$. The condition implies normality since $n^g=n[n,g]\in N$. The <group> $G$ is a <powerful p-group> if $[G,G]\le G^p$, equivalently if $G$ itself is <powerfully embedded>. For a <finite p-group>, the <Burnside basis theorem> gives $d(Q)=\dim_{\mathbb F_p}Q/\Phi(Q)$, and $\Phi(Q)=Q^p[Q,Q]$. Thus for powerful $Q$, $d(Q)=\dim Q/Q^p$.
We prove $d(H)\le d(G)$ by induction on $|G|$, with the trivial <group> immediate. The supplied embedding result applied to $N=G$ makes $G^p$ <powerfully embedded>, and hence powerful. It is a proper <subgroup> when $G\ne1$, because $G^p=\Phi(G)$ is proper in a nontrivial <finite p-group>. Set
$$
K=H\cap G^p,\quad V=G/G^p,\quad W=G^p/G^{p^2},\quad A=HG^p/G^p\le V.
$$
All the displayed quotients are <elementary abelian>. The supplied onto <homomorphism> $\theta:V\to W$, $xG^p\mapsto x^pG^{p^2}$, is therefore linear. Write $v=\dim V=d(G)$, $w=\dim W=d(G^p)$, $r=\dim A$, and $t=\dim\theta(A)$.
Since $H/K$ embeds in $V$, $\Phi(H)\le K$. Also
$$
\Phi(K)\le\Phi(H),\qquad\Phi(K)=K^p[K,K]\le(G^p)^p[G^p,G^p]=G^{p^2}.
$$
Here $(G^p)^p=G^{p^2}$ is the iterated-power convention, valid for powerful <groups>. Hence the natural map $K/\Phi(K)\to W$ is defined. The image under this map of the subspace $\Phi(H)/\Phi(K)$ contains $\theta(A)$, because for every $h\in H$ its power $h^p$ lies in $\Phi(H)\cap K$. It follows that
$$
\dim K/\Phi(H)\le d(K)-t.
$$
The <exact sequence> $1\to K/\Phi(H)\to H/\Phi(H)\to H/K\to1$ consists of <elementary abelian groups>, and $\dim H/K=r$. By induction inside $G^p$, $d(K)\le d(G^p)=w$. Therefore
$$
d(H)=r+\dim K/\Phi(H)\le r+w-t=w+\dim\ker(\theta|_A)\le w+\dim\ker\theta=v.
$$
This proves \b[$d(H)\le d(G)$], including <subgroups> $H$ that are not themselves powerful.
The <rank of a profinite group> is $\operatorname{rk}(P)=\sup\{d(K):K\le P\text{ closed}\}$, where $d(K)$ is its least topological generator number. If $P$ has finite rank then every <closed subgroup>, including the <open subgroup> $H$, has no larger rank. Conversely suppose $H$ has rank $r<\infty$. Its <normal core> $C=\bigcap_{g\in P}H^g$ is an <open normal subgroup>: there are finitely many conjugates because $H$ has finite index. It has rank at most $r$.
For every closed $K\le P$, the <subgroup> $K\cap C$ is normal in $K$ and has at most $r$ topological generators. The quotient $K/(K\cap C)$ embeds in the <finite group> $P/C$. A <finite group> of order at most $M=[P:C]$ has at most $\lfloor\log_2M\rfloor$ generators: in a minimal sequential generating list every strict enlargement at least doubles the <subgroup> order. Lift such quotient generators and adjoin generators of $K\cap C$. Their closed generated <subgroup> contains the <group homomorphism kernel> and maps onto the quotient, so equals $K$. Consequently
$$
\boxed{\operatorname{rk}(P)\le r+\lfloor\log_2[P:C]\rfloor<\infty.}
$$
Thus \b[an <open subgroup> has finite rank exactly when the whole <profinite group> does].
Back to article page