= Solution
Let $P_0,P_1$ be any two rank-one <orthogonal projections>. Choose $0<q<1/N$ and $p=1-(N-1)q$, so $p>q$, and form the mixed <density operators>
$$
\rho_j=qI+(p-q)P_j.
$$
They have the same <spectrum>. If <density operator controllability> holds, a reachable $U$ obeys $U\rho_0U^\dagger=\rho_1$, and subtraction of $qI$ gives $UP_0U^\dagger=P_1$. Thus \b[density operator controllability implies pure-state controllability], even if its definition is phrased using only mixed density operators.
The converse is false in general. For $N=4$, the full <compact symplectic group> $Sp(2)$ is transitive on the complex unit sphere: identify $\mathbb C^4$ with $\mathbb H^2$, extend any quaternionic unit vector to an orthonormal quaternionic basis, and map one such basis to another. This gives <pure-state controllability>. Yet the invariant in part (d) prevents it from connecting the indicated isospectral mixed <density operators>, so it fails <density operator controllability>. This counterexample uses the full symplectic group, not an assertion that every parameter choice in part (c) generates it.
For $N=2$, the converse is true. Every <density operator> has the form $\rho=qI+(p-q)P$ for a rank-one $P$, with $p+q=1$. If $p\ne q$, pure-state control of $P$ controls its entire fixed-spectrum <unitary orbit of a density operator>. If $p=q=1/2$, the orbit contains only $I/2$. Therefore \b[the two controllability notions coincide for a qubit]. The Lie classification gives the same conclusion, since $Sp(1)=SU(2)$.
Back to article page