= Solution
By symmetry the normalized <covariance matrix> has the form $\eta=\begin{pmatrix}V&W\\W&V\end{pmatrix}$. Substituting the matrices from part (c) into the <normalized stationary fluctuation-dissipation relation for a reaction network>, $M\eta+\eta M^{\mathsf T}=D$, gives
$$
\frac2\tau\begin{pmatrix}V+EW&W+EV\\W+EV&V+EW\end{pmatrix}
=\frac1{\tau\mu}\begin{pmatrix}2&E\\E&2\end{pmatrix}.
$$
Hence $V+EW=1/\mu$ and $W+EV=E/(2\mu)$. Solving these two equations gives the <linear noise of two species with joint removal>:
$$
\boxed{V=\frac{2-E^2}{2\mu(1-E^2)},\qquad
W=-\frac{E}{2\mu(1-E^2)},\qquad
\eta=\frac1{2\mu(1-E^2)}\begin{pmatrix}2-E^2&-E\\-E&2-E^2\end{pmatrix}.}
$$
For $E=0$ the normalized variance is $1/\mu$ and the covariance is zero, as expected for independent immigration–death processes. For $E>0$, $V=1/\mu+E^2/(2\mu(1-E^2))$ exceeds this independent value and $W<0$. The <correlation coefficient> is
$$
\rho=\frac WV=-\frac{E}{2-E^2}\longrightarrow-1\quad(E\to1).
$$
This negative stationary correlation is compatible with positive instantaneous joint-removal noise: the slow difference mode amplifies fluctuations of opposite signs in the two populations.
The symmetric and antisymmetric <eigenvectors> diagonalize all three matrices. Their normalized covariance eigenvalues are
$$
\eta_+=V+W=\frac{2+E}{2\mu(1+E)},\qquad
\eta_-=V-W=\frac{2-E}{2\mu(1-E)}.
$$
The corresponding restoring rates are $(1+E)/\tau=\beta+2C\mu$ and $(1-E)/\tau=\beta$. Thus the sum mode retains finite fluctuations, with $\eta_+\to3/(4\mu)$, whereas the difference mode becomes arbitrarily noisy. In particular, at a fixed nonzero mean, or along $\beta\to0$ at fixed $\lambda,C>0$ so $\mu\to\sqrt{\lambda/C}$,
$$
\boxed{V\sim\frac1{4\mu(1-E)}\to+\infty,\qquad
W\sim-\frac1{4\mu(1-E)}\to-\infty.}
$$
The <Fano factor> of either population is $\mu V=(2-E^2)/(2(1-E^2))$, which diverges as $E\to1$ regardless of how the mean is varied. Unnormalized variances are $\mu^2V$ and covariance $\mu^2W$, so their absolute magnitudes also depend on the parameter path through $\mu$.
The <phase plane> in part (b) explains the singularity. At $\beta=0$, the mean-field system has a whole hyperbola of equilibria, rather than an isolated restoring state. A perturbation in the species difference selects another point on that curve. In the actual stochastic reaction network, joint complex formation still leaves $X_1-X_2$ unchanged, but the two constant-rate births change it by $+1$ and $-1$, each at rate $\lambda$. Therefore <exclusive joint removal has a diffusing difference mode>:
$$
\operatorname{Var}(X_1(t)-X_2(t))=\operatorname{Var}(X_1(0)-X_2(0))+2\lambda t.
$$
Its <continuous-time symmetric simple random walk> on the integers has no normalizable stationary distribution, so there is \b[no finite stationary covariance at $E=1$]. The divergence as $E\uparrow1$ signals both the loss of difference-mode restoration and eventual failure of the small-fluctuation <moment closure>; near the limit, the computed normalized variances need not remain small even when the individual mean populations are large.
Back to article page