= Solution
The proposed <generalized additive model> retains the binary response and <logit link>, but replaces the linear age effect by a smooth function:
$$
Y_i\sim\operatorname{Bernoulli}(p_i),\qquad
\log\frac{p_i}{1-p_i}=\alpha+f(a_i)+\gamma d_i,\qquad\sum_i f(a_i)=0.
$$
A penalized <cubic regression spline> represents $f$; frailty remains a parametric coefficient. The plotted age smooth is centered, so its vertical values represent an age contribution to <log odds>, not probabilities or the entire fitted predictor.
\b[The plot gives no evidence that the nonlinear model improves the mean structure.] The fitted curve is essentially a straight descending line, and the label `s(age,1)` reports <effective degrees of freedom> close to one, consistent with a linear effect. The widening bands near the ends reflect sparse data and increasing uncertainty, not detected curvature. A linear-age <logistic regression> is therefore adequate on this evidence and simpler to interpret. A formal comparative claim would need a suitable test or predictive/model-selection criterion, but the figure supplies no reason to retain extra nonlinear flexibility.
Back to article page
