The conditions of regularity at and select the radial vibrations of a circular membrane as an eigenvalue problem. Multiply by and integrate. Integration by parts gives
The boundary term vanishes by regularity and . For a nonzero eigenfunction the denominator is positive; the numerator could vanish only for a constant function, and the outer condition would then make that function zero. Consequently
This also proves reality without presuming real-valued eigenfunctions. Explicitly, regular solutions are Bessel functions of the first kind , and the positive zeros of give the discrete spectrum.