= Rubblising-to-dispersal collision-rate ratio
{title2=$R_{\rm rub}/R_{\rm cc}=(Q_D^*/Q_s)^{(\alpha-1)/3}$}
Consider equal-density <planetesimals> with projectile differential number distribution $n(d)\propto d^{-\alpha}$, $\alpha>1$, and a fixed encounter speed. For projectiles small compared with a target of <diameter> $D$, the minimum projectile diameter needed to exceed <specific impact energy> $Q$ is proportional to $Q^{1/3}$. If this threshold is well below the upper projectile cutoff, integration over the projectile population gives a collision rate $R(>Q)\propto Q^{(1-\alpha)/3}$.
Write the <catastrophic disruption threshold> as $Q_D^*=Q_s+Q_g$, with strength term $Q_s=Q_aD^{-a}$ and gravity term $Q_g=Q_bD^b$. Let $R_{\rm rub}=R(>Q_s)$ count all strength-shattering impacts and $R_{\rm cc}=R(>Q_D^*)$ count dispersive impacts. Then
$$
\frac{R_{\rm rub}}{R_{\rm cc}}=\left(\frac{Q_D^*}{Q_s}\right)^{(\alpha-1)/3}.
$$
With this inclusive convention, the rate of <rubblising collisions> that leave a bound remnant is $R_{\rm rub}-R_{\rm cc}$, rather than $R_{\rm rub}$ alone.
For $a=1/2$, $b=3/2$ and $\alpha=3$, define $D_w$ as the actual minimum of $Q_D^*$ at the <strength-gravity disruption transition>. Differentiation gives $Q_b/Q_a=1/(3D_w^2)$, so
$$
\frac{R_{\rm rub}}{R_{\rm cc}}=
\left[1+\frac13\left(\frac D{D_w}\right)^2\right]^{2/3}
\sim3^{-2/3}\left(\frac D{D_w}\right)^{4/3}
$$
in the gravity-dominated limit. Defining the crossover instead by $Q_s=Q_g$ changes the reference diameter and the apparent coefficient, but not the collision-rate scaling. Variable speeds, comparable projectile and target sizes, and finite-cutoff corrections require a different collision integral.
Back to article page