Deuteron D-state admixture 2026-10-20
The deuteron has a dominant component and a smaller component coupled by the nuclear tensor force. The electric quadrupole moment rules out a purely isotropic S wave spatial state. A D-state probability depends on the chosen nuclear Hamiltonian and current approximation; it is not an independently model-free observable.
An S wave has and positive parity. The deuteron's therefore requires a spin-one-half triplet state, . The two-nucleon isospin description makes this the antisymmetric channel. Its existence proves sufficient attraction to bind in the -dominated channel.
A spin one-half pair could also form . The absence of a bound deuteron indicates that the singlet interaction does not bind, not that it is everywhere repulsive. Together with triplet binding, this shows that a spin-independent central attraction is insufficient. No radial excited bound level also constrains the strength and range: the attraction supports only a shallow low-energy bound state.
For identical neutrons or protons, two-particle isospin has and is symmetric. At even , spatial exchange is symmetric, so the Pauli exclusion principle requires an antisymmetric spin state, . A low-energy or pair cannot occupy the deuteron's channel. With approximate charge independence of nuclear forces, their singlet strong interaction corresponds to the unbound neutron-proton singlet; proton-proton electrostatic repulsion further disfavors binding. There is no bound dineutron or diproton in these physical low-energy channels. The inference uses charge independence and singlet-channel behavior; the deuteron's quantum numbers alone do not constrain every imaginable potential.
In a pure stretched state both spins point along the total angular momentum, with no orbital contribution. The nuclear magnetic moment would beThe measured differs. More decisively, a pure S wave spatial state is isotropic and has zero electric quadrupole moment. Its nonzero value requires a nonspherical component of the quantum charge distribution.
Positive parity allows even ; coupling to permits and . The state contains a deuteron D-state admixture:with radial wavefunctions implicit. A nuclear tensor force couples the orbital components. The quadrupole moment involves their interference as well as a D-state contribution, making it sensitive to a small admixture. This is a quantum angular correlation, not two particles permanently fixed in space.
In the nonrelativistic one-body magnetic-moment approximation,The D-state coupling has and at ; the proton supplies approximately half the relative orbital magnetic moment. ThusThe robust conclusion is a predominantly S wave state with a small tensor-induced D wave component. The 4% estimate is model dependent: exchange currents and other corrections also affect the magnetic moment, and a wavefunction component probability is not itself a uniquely measured observable.[ref]
Modern Theory of Nuclear Forces by Evgeny Epelbaum and others. §I.F, Observables and not-so observable quantities; §II.B, spin-dependent nuclear interactions