Write and . Suppose first that for , so no critical hit occurs before the final iterate. Set . The case is the defining identity. If and , evenness of and oddness of away from zero give
Induction proves the sign lift of an even map formula
on noncritical orbit segments. A final zero value is harmless; using oddness at zero in a subsequent step is not.
The PDF's assertion that this holds for every is false with its stated convention. For , choose . Then , so
but the proposed right side for is . This explicit counterexample identifies the missing noncritical qualification. An exact recurrence valid even at critical hits can instead be written with and : start with , and update
The second rule resets the sign because independently of the previous sign. This proves the intended identity wherever it is valid and accounts for the exceptional critical itineraries without changing the map's definition.