For a short Weierstrass equation of an elliptic curve with coefficients in the p-adic integers, a point with nonintegral has valuations and for some integer : the term strictly dominates in the equation, so . Its formal parameter therefore has valuation . These points, together with the identity, form the formal neighborhood of the identity, with parameter in and the elliptic formal group law over the p-adic integers. For a point with , the equation gives too.
The formal neighborhood has no nontrivial torsion. Multiplication by an integer coprime to has series and preserves , so any torsion there must have -power order. If , part (i) gives , contradicting .
The printed hypotheses also allow . In that case, a nontrivial torsion point in the formal neighborhood would have order a power of two and hence yield a point of order two in that neighborhood. But every nonidentity point of order two on a short Weierstrass equation of an elliptic curve has and a root of the monic cubic over the p-adic integers . Such a root lies in the p-adic integers, so it cannot belong to the formal neighborhood, whose nonidentity points have nonintegral coordinates. This excludes the remaining case. This is the torsion-free formal subgroup for a short Weierstrass equation. Thus every affine torsion point satisfies
With good reduction, the reduction homomorphism has kernel exactly this torsion-free formal neighborhood. Its restriction to the torsion subgroup is therefore injective, proving the required subgroup isomorphism. The short model over the p-adic integers is essential to the prime-two argument; no blanket torsion-injectivity assertion for arbitrary models is needed.
The Lutz–Nagell theorem says that for a nonsingular short equation with , every nonidentity rational torsion point of an elliptic curve has , and either or
This is a necessary condition for torsion, not a converse.
To prove integrality, fix a prime . If , the term dominates the right side of the equation. Hence , so , for some . The parameter has valuation and identifies the point with the formal neighbourhood of the identity, namely the formal group of an elliptic curve evaluated on .
For odd , this group is a torsion-free group by the logarithm argument of Question 2. For , use the special short-model structure. Negation sends exactly to , so the formal multiplication series is odd and has integral coefficients:
If , the first term has valuation and all the others have valuation at least . Thus , and no iteration of doubling kills a nonzero point. Multiplication by an odd integer has unit linear coefficient and also cannot kill it. This proves the torsion-free formal subgroup for a short Weierstrass equation, including at two. Consequently a rational torsion point of an elliptic curve cannot have at any prime. Its is integral, and the equation then makes its rational integral too.
For the divisibility conclusion suppose . Then and is also a rational torsion point of an elliptic curve, so is integral. Its tangent slope satisfies . Thus ; a rational number with integral square is itself integral. In particular . Reduce the supplied polynomial identity modulo : both terms on the left are divisible by , so the right side is too. This is the divisibility proof in the Nagell–Lutz theorem.
For the specific curve, . The computed equality makes a point of exact order three. The coordinate has square not dividing , so has infinite order. To decide , use the already computed point . Its -coordinate has even square, which cannot divide the odd number , so that sum has infinite order. Since is torsion, must have infinite order as well. has order three; and both have infinite order.