Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 60 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
An oscillatory integral defines a distribution by cancellation, even when its oscillatory integral amplitude is not integrable in frequency. We use symbol class , where is open and . An oscillatory integral amplitude belongs to this class if it is smooth and, for every compact set and all multi-indices ,In symbol calculus, spatial derivatives preserve the order and frequency derivatives lower it. The fixed number is independent of ; this will produce a finite global order of a distribution, although continuity constants may depend on .
A phase function is real and smooth on , is positively homogeneous of degree one in , and has nonzero total differential there:This positive homogeneity is required at nonzero frequency; arbitrary smooth low-frequency modifications give the equivalent version homogeneous only for large . In particular, smoothness at zero is not an additional requirement on a general homogeneous phase function. The integral over bounded frequencies is a smooth function of : spatial derivatives of the phase have size near zero, uniformly on compact spatial sets and frequency directions.
Choose a cutoff function equal to one near zero. The proposed meaning of the oscillatory integral distribution isExistence and cutoff independence of an oscillatory integral require a proof. Split using a fixed frequency cutoff function, with supported in a bounded ball and zero for . The low-frequency part is already absolutely integrable. On nonzero frequency setThe positive homogeneity and nonvanishing total differential of the phase function imply for : normalize to the compact unit sphere in frequency. Direct differentiation gives .
The coefficients of have symbol class order , and its frequency coefficients have order zero. If these coefficients are and , the formal transpose of a differential operator isThus the symbol order reduction by a phase integration operator is : the first sum has an order- coefficient, and the second contains a frequency derivative. In applying this to , every application also differentiates at most once. Repeated integration by parts, in both and , consequently gives for an integer There are no spatial boundary terms because has compact support, and the frequency cutoff removes frequency boundary terms. Derivatives of are bounded uniformly by constants times on their annular support. The transformed integrand is therefore bounded in absolute value byThis is integrable in frequency dimensions. Pointwise the transformed integrand tends to , so the dominated convergence theorem establishesThe limit is independent of the expanding cutoff, the fixed splitting cutoff, and the admissible , since each formula is the limit of the same truncated integral. Derivatives landing on the expanding cutoff can also be estimated directly by , which tends to zero. In particular,This proves continuity on the space of test functions and the finite order of an oscillatory integral distribution. The same works for all compact sets. When , is possible and the original frequency integral is absolutely integrable; cancellation is needed for general .
The singular support theorem states thatBy positive homogeneity, frequencies can be restricted to the unit sphere, so this projected set is closed locally in . More precisely, the stationary-direction bound for singular support restricts the frequency directions to the closed conic support of an oscillatory amplitude; using a closed directional support avoids losing limits occurring at arbitrarily high frequency. The simpler displayed bound is sufficient here.
To prove the bound, take outside the displayed stationary set. On a sufficiently small spatial neighborhood and all unit frequency directions, is bounded below. The frequency-only operatorsatisfies , and its formal transpose lowers symbol class order by one. A spatial derivative of order of has amplitude order at most . Applying the frequency integration by parts more than times makes that derivative absolutely integrable, uniformly on smaller compact sets. Every spatial derivative therefore exists and is continuous there. The oscillatory integral distribution is a smooth function near , proving the singular support assertion.
For the linear transport equation, use spacetime , frequency , andThis is a valid phase function, because at nonzero frequency; the oscillatory integral amplitude is in symbol class order zero. The Fourier representation of the Dirac delta function gives the transport of a Dirac point mass:Its rigorous spacetime distribution pairing is . Consequentlywhere the endpoints vanish since a spacetime test function has compact support in . At each fixed , , so weak convergence of distributions gives as . This is the required initial trace.
Finally, , so the singular support theorem confines singularities to . In fact equality holds: is a nonzero order-zero distribution on that trajectory and vanishes off it. A smooth function supported on this set of empty interior must vanish, so cannot be smooth in any neighborhood of a point of the trajectory. ThusThe method of characteristics also proves uniqueness among solutions with a distributional initial trace: the change of variables turns the linear transport equation into . Such a distribution is constant in ; pairing with spatial test functions reduces this assertion to a distribution with zero derivative is constant. Its initial trace fixes , so the moving Dirac delta distribution above is the unique solution. There is transport of the singularity along the characteristic and no smoothing.