For aplane material-coordinate elastic wave with u=(0,w(X1,t),0), set q=w,X1. The longitudinal equation is 0=∂X1P11(1,q,0). Arbitrary nonuniform pure transverse profiles thus require the displayed constitutive compatibility, which does not follow from isotropy alone. If it holds and τ′(q)>0, the shear equation closes as ρ0wtt=∂X1τ(q) with speed c(q)2=τ′(q)/ρ0.