Solution

ID: past-exam-of-the-analytic-topology-and-axiomatic-set-theory-course-of-the-university-of-oxford/2010/b/6/d/ii/solution

Assume a nonempty set has no membership-minimal element, so for every there is . Consider the formula .
It is progressive: if every element of is outside but , the assumed absence of a minimal element supplies , contradicting that hypothesis. The membership induction theorem therefore implies for every set . This contradicts .
Thus every nonempty set contains an element with , exactly the Axiom of foundation:
Only the induction schema and elementary set reasoning were needed; no prior use of Axiom of foundation occurs in the proof.

New to topics? Read the docs here!