Solution

ID: past-exam-of-the-condensed-matter-physics-course-of-the-university-of-oxford/2019/4/e/solution

Let be uniform, with dimensionless spin operators . The factor in the source Hamiltonian removes double counting of pairs. Decoupling about a uniform polarization gives the one-site mean-field theory Hamiltonian
A body-centred-cubic site has eight nearest neighbors and six next-nearest neighbors, so
For a spin one half in this effective field, the mean-field self-consistency equation is
Linearizing at the continuous onset gives , hence
Equivalently, the general spin- result is . The antiferromagnetic next-nearest-neighbor exchange reduces the uniform ordering scale rather than contributing its absolute magnitude. The negative nuclear g-factor does not change this exchange instability; aligning the spins also aligns their moments with one another.
For these particular competing couplings, the uniform mode is indeed the largest exchange eigenvalue. Writing , and gives
with equality at modulo reciprocal lattice vectors. To see the bound, replace a negative by its absolute value for an upper bound, let , and use . The expression is at most , whose maximum on is five. Thus another modulation does not preempt the stated ferromagnetic onset at this level of mean-field theory. Fluctuations can change the actual transition temperature.

New to topics? Read the docs here!