 Solution

Suppose $G$ is a representable functor, with a natural isomorphism $\theta :\mathcal{C}(R,-)\to G$. Put $r={\theta }_R(1_R)$. For any $(A,a)$ in the comma category $(1\downarrow G)$, the representing bijection gives a unique $f:R\to A$ with ${\theta }_A(f)=a$. By naturality, ${\theta }_A(f)=G(f)(r)$, exactly the condition for $f:(R,r)\to (A,a)$. Hence $(R,r)$ is an initial object.

Conversely, if $(R,r)$ is an initial object, thenis a bijection for each $A$: existence and uniqueness are precisely initiality applied to every $(A,a)$. For $h:A\to B$, $G(h){\theta }_A(f)=G(hf)(r)={\theta }_B(hf)$, proving naturality. Thus $r$ is a universal element and $\theta$ is a representation of a functor. Being representable is equivalent to the singleton comma category having an initial object.