 Solution

For the model $M$ constructed in part (a), the collapsing map $X\to M$ is a bijection. The Downward Lowenheim-Skolem theorem supplied countable $X$, so $M$ is externally countable. It is infinite because it satisfies the axiom of infinity. ConsequentlyThis is external cardinality. A countable transitive model still regards many of its own sets and ordinals as uncountable, because external enumerations need not belong to it.