 Solution

The supplied row-hook formula isConsequently $h\in H_i(\lambda )$ exactly when $h_i-h\ge 0$ and $h_i-h$ is not one of $h_{i+1},\dots ,h_m$. Since $h_i-h\le h_i<h_j$ for $j<i$, this is equivalent to $h_i-h\notin X$. We have proved the hook criterion in a beta set

If $ef$ is a hook length, the beta-set interpretation gives a bead at some position $b$ and a gap at $b-ef$. In the finite progressionthe first position is occupied and the last is empty. Some consecutive pair is therefore a bead followed by a gap. Their distance is $e$, so the criterion gives a hook of length $e$. This proves the divisor closure of hook lengths.