A point at distance a from the axis of aradius-rcylinder rolling downhill at constant axis speed v has x˙=v[cosα+(a/r)cosθ], y˙=−v[sinα+(a/r)sinθ]. For 0≤α<π/2, the existence of x˙=0, y˙>0 is equivalent to a>r. At a=r the relevant zero-horizontal-velocity point is stationary, so a point within or on the rolling cylinder never has strictly vertical upward motion.