With J=0, define ωs2=4π2k/m and ωc=qB/m. Then re=ωs2r0/(ωs2+ωc2/4), the radial frequency is Ω=ωs2+ωc2/4, and release at r0 gives r=re+(r0−re)cosΩt with ϕ˙=−ωc/2. The physical solution requires r>0. If 2re<r0, the formal oscillation reaches zero and cannot be continued asa negative ringradius without a new collapse model.