Embedded associated prime 2026-10-06
An associated prime of a module is embedded when it is not minimal over . For example, in the nonzero class of has annihilator , while the unique minimal prime is . Embedded primes record annihilators which are invisible if one retains only the reduced irreducible components.
For a Noetherian ring and a proper ideal , every minimal prime over is an associated prime of a module . The localized quotient has one prime, so its finitely generated maximal ideal is nilpotent and its socle is nonzero. An element with annihilator can be lifted to the quotient. Clearing denominators for a finite generating set of gives a nonzero element with annihilator exactly .
A prime ideal is minimal over if and no strictly smaller prime contains . An associated prime of a module is an annihilator of an individual nonzero element which happens to be prime. For the quotient module this reads
where . This is the annihilator of an individual element, rather than necessarily the annihilator of the whole quotient.
Minimal primes exist because is proper. First choose a maximal ideal containing . Within the primes contained in it and containing , an intersection of any decreasing chain is again prime. Indeed, if is in the intersection and is absent from one member, then belongs to that member and to every smaller member; it also belongs to every larger member. The intersection is still proper and contains . Zorn's lemma, applied with reverse inclusion, produces a minimal prime. This proves existence of minimal primes over a proper ideal, even without the Noetherian hypothesis.
Now fix a minimal prime and put . The localization at a prime ideal is nonzero and is a Noetherian local ring. By prime ideal correspondence for localization, its only prime is . Write this maximal ideal as . It is the nilradical; since it is finitely generated and each generator is nilpotent, some power of is zero. Explicitly, if its generators have nilpotence exponents , every product of degree vanishes.
Choose the smallest such that , and choose a nonzero element in ; when , choose . Its annihilator over is exactly . Represent it as with . Multiplication by the unit shows that has the same annihilator and remains nonzero.
Let generate in . For each , the equality supplies such that in . Put and . Its localization is nonzero, so , and every element of kills it. Conversely, an element outside becomes a unit and cannot kill the nonzero element . Therefore
The key step in minimal primes are associated primes is clearing denominators for a finite generating set of ; that is where Noetherianity is used.
For an embedded associated prime, take and . Its radical is , so is its unique minimal prime. The nonzero class of satisfies
Indeed, is equivalent to by cancellation in the polynomial domain. Thus is associated but is not minimal, since . For comparison, , exhibiting the minimal associated prime as well.