Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2014 ia Paper 3 12A b i Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-06
Under a proper rotation matrix , invariance of a Cartesian second-rank tensor reads , equivalently . The half-turn forces all entries mixing the direction with the plane to vanish. Thus consists of a planar block and the entry .
Commutation with the planar quarter-turn gives . This block already commutes with every planar rotation. Now use the half-turn : on the planar block its conjugation fixes and sends to , so invariance forces . ThereforeThe formula uses the Kronecker delta and is sufficient as well as necessary: rotations preserving the unoriented -axis fix both and . This is an axially invariant second-rank tensor with the planar antisymmetric part removed by the horizontal half-turn.
The six-element dihedral group generated by the displayed rotations already forces every invariant second-rank tensor to have the same form as an axially invariant second-rank tensor. The axial threefold rotation eliminates mixed entries and leaves only a planar scalar plus a planar antisymmetric part; the transverse half-turn eliminates the latter. No smaller finite subgroup suffices: cyclic rotation groups retain an axial antisymmetric tensor, while a four-element noncyclic rotation group retains arbitrary diagonal tensors along its three mutually perpendicular half-turn axes.