Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2001 iii Paper 72 4 c Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For an auxiliary field varying slowly over lattice distances, measure in lattice-spacing units and replace the squared difference by . The long-wavelength action becomesThis is the Euclidean path integral of a one-coordinate quantum particle, with the classical spatial coordinate serving as imaginary time and . To see the correspondence at the operator level, time-slice it by and use the symmetric kernelActing on a smooth test function, Gaussian integration gives . Thus the continuum auxiliary-field transfer operator for an Ising chain is , whereMultiplying kernels and integrating over intermediate fields gives for fixed endpoints, and for periodic fields, up to the normalization already absorbed in . This is the precise classical Ising chain as a quantum particle correspondence. It concerns an imaginary-time transition kernel; it is not the squared modulus of a real-time transition amplitude. The continuum approximation retains smooth long-distance modes, rather than asserting exact equality of the finite-spacing transfer operator with this differential operator.
At , set . Expansion of the local potential givesThe potential is even and grows as at large . It is a symmetric double well precisely whenThe nonzero stationary points satisfy . For , the ratio decreases strictly from 2 to 0: writing , the sign follows from , whose derivative is . Hence there is one minimum on each side when . At the potential instead has a single quartic minimum, and for a single quadratic minimum. Small with fixed positive falls in the double-well regime, but the printed claim requires this coupling condition; alone does not imply it if scales to zero too quickly.
A weak magnetic field givesThe linear term is odd in . For positive , the positive well becomes deeper. If the zero-field minima are , their depth difference to first order is . The magnetic field tilts the symmetric double well and favors the matching spin orientation. A large enough field can eliminate the metastable well.
Finally, two minima do not imply a true finite-temperature phase transition in this one-dimensional chain at fixed finite interaction range . A finite quantum barrier permits quantum tunnelling; the confining one-dimensional Schrödinger operator has a unique symmetric ground state at zero field and a nonzero first excitation gap. The quantum gap corresponds to a finite classical correlation length. A very small gap can mimic ordering on a finite sample, but genuine degeneracy requires a singular limit such as vanishing tunnelling. This distinction is central to interpreting the quantum mapping.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2002 iii Paper 69 4 c Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
With lattice spacing set to one and a smoothly varying auxiliary field, the discrete action becomesThis is precisely the Euclidean path integral of a quantum particle with , mass and potential . With fixed endpoints it gives the transition amplitude , while periodic classical boundary conditions give its trace. The corresponding operator isThis is classical Ising chain as a quantum particle. It is the continuum approximation to the exact positive transfer kernel, so its numerical spectrum is accurate when the relevant auxiliary configurations vary slowly. The transfer-kernel reasoning and the domain-wall argument below also support the qualitative conclusion without treating a continuum approximation as an exact finite-lattice identity.
At zero field write . Expansion givesA double well exists when ; the stationary points satisfy . For there is a single minimum at zero, with the quadratic curvature marginal at equality. Thus a double well is the low-effective-temperature regime of the model, not an unconditional property for every . The exact potential remains confining because at large .
Even when two wells exist, a quantum particle with finite mass and a finite barrier tunnels between them. Its one-dimensional confining Schrödinger operator has a unique, strictly positive ground-state wavefunction. At reflection symmetry makes that state even, so every odd observable has zero expectation. An antisymmetric first excited state is split from it by a positive gap. A spectral expansion of an odd-observable correlation has factors ; the smallest contributing gap therefore gives a finite classical correlation length. The original spin observable, after decoupling, is , which is odd at zero field. HenceA deep well can give an exponentially small quantum tunnelling gap and an extremely long correlation length, which can mimic order in a finite sample, but it does not produce true long-range order.
The classical counterpart is the finite cost of a domain wall. Because the pair sum is doubled, a sharp wall has dimensionless energyAt any finite temperature such walls have nonzero fugacity, divide a long chain into domains and destroy spontaneous magnetization. The range is large for but finite. The zero-temperature limit and an infinite-range limit are singular and must not be interchanged casually with the thermodynamic limit; an infinite-range interaction also requires an extensive normalization before comparing models.
A nonzero tilts the potential: to first order . A positive field favors the positive well and produces positive magnetization. For fixed finite parameters the ground state and classical free energy vary smoothly, so there is no zero-field discontinuity due merely to a double-well bare potential. A discrete broken-symmetry state appears only in an appropriate singular limit, not by ignoring quantum tunnelling.
More generally a local -dimensional classical statistical model can be sliced along one coordinate and represented by a transfer operator. That coordinate becomes imaginary time; the other coordinates become the spatial coordinates of a quantum system. Infinite extent in the transfer direction corresponds to its ground-state, or zero-quantum-temperature, limit. The classical Ising model is thus related to a quantum Ising system in spatial dimensions, with transverse dynamics generated by the transfer operator. For this is quantum mechanics of finitely many local variables, where quantum tunnelling restores symmetry. For the quantum system has infinitely many spatial degrees of freedom and can have distinct symmetry-broken ground states, allowing a classical finite-temperature ordering transition. Locality and anisotropy of the mapping determine the quantum couplings; the dimension correspondence alone does not fix them.