Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2008 iii Paper 18 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
A simply connected space is path-connected and has trivial fundamental group, equivalently every based loop is null-homotopic. The Whitehead theorem says that a map of CW complexes inducing isomorphisms on all homotopy groups is a homotopy equivalence. Its homological Whitehead theorem form says that a map between simply connected CW complexes, in particular finite ones, is a homotopy equivalence if it induces isomorphisms on integral homology. The latter implication follows from the relative Hurewicz theorem and the ordinary Whitehead theorem; homotopy equivalences necessarily induce homology isomorphisms.
For the attached-cell space , the cellular homology chain complex in positive degrees isDualizing gives the cellular cohomology complex . The last map is injective and its image is primitive because . Its cokernel is , explicitly via . HenceThe van Kampen theorem gives . Moreover is generated by . Since is simply connected, the Hurewicz theorem gives . Choose a map representing that generator. It induces an isomorphism on , and on , while all other reduced homology groups vanish on both sides. The homological Whitehead theorem proves . This is a special case of coprime two-cell attachments to a circle.
It is not homeomorphic to the sphere. Indeed, if it were, its embedded one-skeleton would be a Jordan circle in , with the two open cell interiors as its complementary regions. The Jordan curve theorem and its Schoenflies form identify the closures of those regions with discs. A characteristic map, homeomorphic on the interior of such a disc, has local degree or at an interior point; the boundary homomorphism in relative homology then makes its attaching map on the circle have degree or . This contradicts degrees and . This argument does not require choosing special covering representatives of the attaching maps.
Finally, two compact examples with the same additive cohomology areBoth have , , and zero higher cohomology, by their cellular chain complexes. But their fundamental groups are respectively and the nonabelian free group on two generators, so they cannot be homotopy equivalent. This illustrates that cohomology groups do not determine homotopy type.