Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2012 iii Paper 7 3 f Solution 2026-10-07
We prove compact perturbation invariance of Fredholm operators using a two-sided inverse modulo compact operators. If is Fredholm, decomposeThe restriction of from to its closed range is a bounded bijection, so the bounded inverse theorem supplies a bounded inverse there. Extend that inverse by zero on to obtain a bounded operator . If are the orthogonal projections onto and , respectively, thenBoth and have finite rank.
Set . Products of a compact operator and a bounded operator are compact: on one side compactness preserves compact images, and on the other the bounded operator maps the unit ball into a bounded ball. Hencewhere are compact.
Here is why these identities force to be Fredholm. On , , so part (a) and compactness make finite-dimensional. There is a positive constant withOtherwise unit vectors could satisfy . From and compactness, a subsequence would converge strongly to a unit vector with , which is impossible. The lower bound proves closed range: for a convergent sequence , first discard the kernel components, then the remaining are Cauchy and their limit maps to the desired range limit.
For finite codimension, take the adjoint operator of , giving . The operator is compact: the finite-rank approximation proved in part (e) gives finite-rank adjoints converging in operator norm to , and norm limits of compact operators are compact. On , , so this kernel is finite-dimensional. Finally,Because the range is closed, its cokernel is isomorphic to this finite-dimensional orthogonal complement. This verifies all three Fredholm operator conditions for .
For the converse, start with and perturb by the compact operator . Therefore is Fredholm if and only if is Fredholm, with no self-adjointness assumption.
For bounded and compact , use the Fredholm convention . Applying compact perturbation invariance of Fredholm operators to every shift proves the equality. This general theorem needs no self-adjointness; other definitions of essential spectrum for nonnormal operators must be distinguished.