Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2009 ia Paper 4 12A b Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
Place the four fixed charges at with , and write the moving particle's position as . Introduce its mass , which is needed for an oscillation frequency but is not named in the question. Let . By Coulomb's law and superposition, the moving particle's potential energy isThe electrostatic potential itself is . Put and . Near the centre, a Taylor expansion givesOn summing over the four corners, linear terms cancel. To quadratic order, and , since . Reflection symmetry removes all odd-degree terms. HencewhereThus the centre has zero planar force and a positive-definite planar Hessian matrix . It is a strict local minimum of the constrained potential energy, so it is a stable equilibrium. More explicitly, conservation of the total energy confines sufficiently small-energy motions within a small neighbourhood of this isolated local minimum.
Keeping only the quadratic potential, the two coordinates obey independent small oscillations:Both planar modes have the same angular frequency, and the ordinary frequency isThe planar constraint is essential to this constrained electrostatic equilibrium. Along the perpendicular axis, , so the same stationary point is unstable to unconstrained normal displacements. That also checks the cancellation of the three-dimensional Hessian trace required by Laplace's equation away from charges; it does not contradict the positive-definite restriction to the given plane.