Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2003 iii Paper 27 1 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
The cellular approximation theorem says that a continuous map between CW complexes is homotopic to a cellular map, meaning that it sends each -skeleton into the target's -skeleton. Give , for , its CW complex structure with one zero-cell and one -cell. Its -skeleton is the whole sphere, so the theorem applies and gives the requested result. For use the two zero-cells of . In particular the conclusion isThere is no local-finiteness assumption on .
For completeness, here is a direct proof of the needed case of cellular approximation, including the point-avoidance step. We use three standard facts, stated explicitly. First, a compact subset of a CW complex lies in a finite subcomplex. Second, a continuous map from a smooth manifold into Euclidean space has arbitrarily close smooth approximations, and smooth cutoffs exist around compact subsets of open sets. Third, the Sard theorem says the critical values of a smooth map have measure zero; when the domain dimension is smaller than the target dimension, its entire image has measure zero.
The first fact has a useful short proof. If a compact set met infinitely many open cells, choose one point in each of countably many distinct cells. Closure-finiteness makes every closed cell meet the chosen set, and every subset of it, in finitely many points. The weak topology of a CW complex then makes all those subsets closed. The chosen set is an infinite closed discrete subset of a compact space, a contradiction. Taking the closures of the finitely many cells met proves the claim.
Now lies in a finite subcomplex . Take a top-dimensional open cell of with , and identify its interior with the open unit ball in using its characteristic map. On the open set , write for the coordinate expression. Choose and a smooth cutoff supported in and equal to one near the compact set . By smooth approximation of maps into Euclidean space, choose a smooth with , where . Replace byThe straight-line interpolation is a homotopy supported away from the boundary of the cell and stays inside that cell. Where , we have and hence . By the Sard theorem, choose outside . Where we have , and elsewhere , so the modified map avoids everywhere.
Radial retraction of onto its boundary fixes that boundary. It therefore descends through the characteristic map, including its possibly noninjective boundary identifications, and fixes all other cells of . Composing gives a homotopy whose endpoint misses all of . Remove every cell of dimension greater than in descending order. There are finitely many such cells, so their homotopies concatenate to yield . This proves dimension reduction of sphere maps into CW skeleta. The approximation step is essential: an arbitrary continuous image of can fill a higher-dimensional region, so dimension alone would not supply an omitted point.