First assume . Set . If with , then in the field , so . For an automorphism inducing the root permutation ,
Since fixes and in , every induced permutation has positive sign. The root action is faithful because the roots generate , giving
This is the discriminant criterion for an alternating Galois group.
As printed for arbitrary fields, the assertion is false in characteristic two. Over , the polynomial is irreducible and separable, with roots in . Their difference is one, so the discriminant is the square . Nevertheless its Galois group is , whereas is trivial. In characteristic two the permutation signs become indistinguishable as field elements; square discriminants in characteristic two therefore cannot detect the alternating subgroup in this way.
For a depressed quartic
with roots summing to zero, set
The cubic resolvent of a quartic is
The symmetric group acts on the three partitions of four roots into two unordered pairs. The resulting homomorphism has kernel the Klein four-group . If is a square and the characteristic is not two, the discriminant criterion for an alternating Galois group gives , and its image on the three resolvent roots lies in .
For an irreducible quartic, is transitive on four roots, and its only possibilities inside are and . The resolvent is irreducible exactly when the image acts transitively on its three roots, equivalently when that image is . Thus
The printed statement omits the needed irreducibility hypothesis on . Literally it is false: has square discriminant and Galois group , and its resolvent is irreducible. Without quartic irreducibility, a reducible resolvent only implies , allowing the trivial group, , or .
For the specified polynomial ,
Its resolvent is . Modulo this is , which has no root in and is therefore an irreducible cubic. The quartic is given to be irreducible, so the preceding criterion yields
If a monic polynomial has roots in a splitting field, its polynomial discriminant is
It is a symmetric polynomial in the roots, so it belongs to the base field; it is nonzero exactly when is a separable polynomial.
Put
the Vandermonde determinant. A root permutation sends to . Hence the Galois group of a polynomial is contained in the alternating group exactly when every Galois automorphism fixes , which by the fixed-field property is equivalent to . This implies that is a square in . Conversely, if for , then , so . The Galois group therefore fixes and consists of even permutations. This proves the discriminant criterion for an alternating Galois group.
Now let
The rational root theorem shows that none of is a root, so this cubic is irreducible over . The discriminant of a depressed cubic is
This is not a square in , so the Galois group of an irreducible cubic is over .
Over , the discriminant is the square
The cubic remains irreducible: a root in the degree-two extension would generate over both a degree-three field, by irreducibility, and a subfield of a degree-two field, contradicting the tower law for field extensions. Its Galois group over is consequently .
For a separable polynomial in characteristic two, the Vandermonde determinant of its roots is fixed by every Galois automorphism: root permutations change it only by a sign, and in . It therefore lies in . Its square, multiplied by the square of the appropriate leading-coefficient power for a nonmonic polynomial, is the polynomial discriminant. Thus being a square does not detect containment of the Galois group in the alternating group. For example over has discriminant one and Galois group , while is trivial. The discriminant criterion for an alternating Galois group requires characteristic different from two.