Eckmann-Hilton argument (source code)

= Eckmann-Hilton argument
{c}
{wiki=Eckmann–Hilton_argument}

Suppose two <binary operations> $*$ and $\cdot$ on one <set> share an <identity element> $e$ and satisfy the interchange rule
$$
(a*b)\cdot(c*d)=(a\cdot c)*(b\cdot d).
$$
Then the operations coincide, because
$$
a\cdot b=(a*e)\cdot(e*b)=(a\cdot e)*(e\cdot b)=a*b.
$$
They are also <commutative>:
$$
a\cdot b=(e*a)\cdot(b*e)=(e\cdot b)*(a\cdot e)=b*a=b\cdot a.
$$
These substitutions prove the <Eckmann-Hilton argument> without cancellation assumptions. In the <fundamental group of a topological group>, the two operations are loop concatenation and pointwise <group> multiplication. They share the constant loop as identity on <homotopy classes>, so the <fundamental group> is <Abelian>.