Suppose two binary operations and on one set share an identity element and satisfy the interchange ruleThen the operations coincide, becauseThey are also commutative:These substitutions prove the Eckmann-Hilton argument without cancellation assumptions. In the fundamental group of a topological group, the two operations are loop concatenation and pointwise group multiplication. They share the constant loop as identity on homotopy classes, so the fundamental group is Abelian.
For , pointwise multiplication of based cube maps into a topological group induces the ordinary addition in its homotopy group . Concatenation and pointwise multiplication share an identity and satisfy the interchange rule, so the Eckmann-Hilton argument identifies the two operations. In particular, the -th power map induces multiplication by on every homotopy group, for all integers .
Articles by others on the same topic
The Eckmann–Hilton argument is a concept in category theory and homotopy theory that plays a role in the context of algebraic structures such as monoids and operads. It particularly addresses the interactions between two operations defined on a space or an algebraic structure when these operations are defined in a certain way, especially in relation to commutativity and associativity.