Even primitive groups of safe-prime degree Created 2026-10-14 Updated 2026-11-05
Every nontrivial normal subgroup of a faithful primitive group of prime degree is transitive and contains a Sylow -subgroup . Its normalizer in has order . For a proper normal subgroup , the Frattini argument gives ; unless , its -normalizer is the full order- normalizer, while . The Burnside transfer theorem gives a characteristic normal -complement in . This complement is normal in and cannot be transitive because its order is prime to , so it is trivial. Thus and .
Frattini lifting of nilpotence 2026-10-14
Let in a finite group. If contains and is a nilpotent group, every Sylow subgroup of has . The Frattini argument gives , and the defining non-generator property of forces . Hence is a nilpotent group.
Hall subgroup existence in soluble groups Created 2026-10-07 Updated 2026-11-05
Every finite soluble group has a Hall subgroup for each prime set. Induct on the group order using an elementary abelian minimal normal subgroup. In the coprime hard case, lift a minimal normal subgroup of the quotient, choose its Sylow subgroup, and apply the Frattini argument. A proper normalizer reduces the order; a normal Sylow subgroup allows induction in its quotient. This proves existence without assuming an independent complement theorem.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2004 iii Paper 2 1 b Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Put and choose a Sylow subgroup of . Since is normal, the Frattini argument gives : for , the Sylow subgroups and of are conjugate by an element of , leaving an element of . The non-generator property of the Frattini subgroup proved above forces . Thus every Sylow subgroup of is normal. Distinct such Sylow subgroups commute because their group commutators lie in their trivial intersection. Hence is a nilpotent normal subgroup, and
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2004 iii Paper 2 1 e Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Put and let be the full preimage of in . The preceding part gives , so the normal nilpotent image lies in .
For the reverse inclusion, choose a Sylow subgroup of . Its image is the unique Sylow subgroup of the nilpotent group , hence a characteristic subgroup there and normal in . Thus . The subgroup is also a Sylow subgroup of : the p-part of lies in , because is a Sylow subgroup of the normal subgroup of . Apply the Frattini argument to :The Frattini subgroup property forces . Hence every Sylow subgroup of is normal, so is a nilpotent group and . Together the inclusions proveThis is Frattini lifting of nilpotence; simply calling an extension of nilpotent groups nilpotent would not establish it.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2005 iii Paper 1 4 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For of finite subgroup index, let and choose a right-coset transversal for the cosets . For each writeThe transfer homomorphism isThe product is taken in the abelianization, so its order is irrelevant. If another transversal has representative for , with , its factor is . The map permutes , so the extra factors cancel in . This proves independence of the transversal. AlsoMultiplying over and again permuting the second indices proves . Thus it is indeed a group homomorphism.
The Burnside transfer theorem states that if a Sylow -subgroup of a finite group satisfies , then has a normal -complement: a normal subgroup of order . The hypothesis first makes abelian. It also makes fusion inside trivial. To prove this, suppose and , using . Both and lie in : the former because is abelian, and the latter because . They are Sylow subgroups of that centralizer. Choose with . Then and , while the central-normalizer hypothesis gives . Thus .
Evaluate transfer to the abelian group on . In the action of on right cosets, a cycle of length contributeswith . This is a conjugate of inside and hence equals by the fusion argument. Summing the cycle lengths therefore givesThe exponent is coprime to , so this power map is an automorphism of the finite abelian -group . Transfer is consequently onto , and its kernel is normal of subgroup index and of order prime to . This proves the theorem. Notice also that a normal -complement consists exactly of the elements of prime-to- order: they map trivially to the -group quotient, while all elements of the complement have such order. It is therefore unique and a characteristic subgroup.
Now let be primitive of degree , with prime. Every nontrivial normal subgroup of a faithful primitive group action is transitive: its orbits form a -invariant block partition, and singleton orbits would make it trivial. Such a subgroup has order divisible by . A Sylow -subgroup has order , since contains only one factor . The normalizer of a regular -cycle in is the affine group on , of order . Translations are even, whereas a generating multiplier gives a -cycle and is odd. Its normalizer in therefore has order .
Suppose is not simple and choose proper. It is transitive, so we can choose . The Frattini argument gives : for each , the subgroup is a Sylow subgroup of and can be conjugated back to within . Since contains and lies in the order- normalizer, it has order or . If its order were , the Burnside theorem applied to would give a normal -complement. A nontrivial such complement cannot be transitive because its order is prime to , contradicting primitivity. It must be trivial, giving , contrary to the choice of . Thus .
The intersection again has order or . If it had order , the whole normalizer would lie in and the Frattini equality would give . Hence . Applying Burnside transfer within gives its normal -complement . By the uniqueness argument, is a characteristic subgroup of , and so normal in . Primitivity again forces this prime-to- subgroup to be trivial. Thus is normal in , and has order . The even primitive groups of safe-prime degree conclusion is
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2010 iii Paper 4 1 ii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For a finite group, define the Frattini subgroup bythe intersection is when there are no maximal subgroups, which for a finite group happens only for . A second definition is the set of non-generators: an element such that always implies .
If and , put in a maximal subgroup . Then , so . Conversely, if , some maximal subgroup omits it; maximality gives , although . This proves equivalence.
Every group automorphism permutes maximal subgroups, so is a characteristic subgroup, in particular a normal subgroup. Alsoa proper would lie in a maximal subgroup containing both factors.
Set and take a Sylow subgroup of . For , normality of makes a Sylow subgroup of . Conjugating inside therefore gives the Frattini argument factorization . The preceding generating property forces . Thus every Sylow subgroup of is normal, and part (i) shows that is a nilpotent group.
Now suppose is a finite p-group. The normalizer condition makes every maximal subgroup normal: and maximality force . The quotient has no proper nontrivial subgroup, hence is cyclic of prime order; its p-power order makes that prime . Consequently every such containswhere the two factors are the commutator subgroup and the subgroup generated by pth powers. Thus .
The quotient is an elementary abelian group, hence a vector space over . If , extend the nonzero vector to a basis and choose a linear functional nonzero on it. Its kernel pulls back to a subgroup of index , a maximal subgroup omitting . Therefore , provingThe two factors in the last formula are multiplied; the superscripted expression in the TeX aid is not the formula printed in the PDF.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 3 1 e Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
We prove Hall subgroup existence in soluble groups by induction on . The trivial group is immediate. Choose a nontrivial minimal normal subgroup , elementary abelian of order by part (c). Induction gives a Hall -subgroup of ; let be its full preimage.
If , then itself is the required subgroup. If and , apply induction inside the soluble subgroup to obtain a Hall -subgroup of . Since and are both -numbers, is Hall in too.
It remains to treat and . Then is a -group. If , the subgroup one works. Otherwise choose a minimal normal subgroup of , an elementary abelian -group with . Let be a Sylow -subgroup of . As and , we have . The permitted Frattini argument givesThe last equality uses and the normality of .
If , then is a power of , hence a -number. Apply induction to and multiply indices as before. If , then is a nontrivial normal -subgroup. Induction in gives a Hall -subgroup whose full preimage in is Hall, since its additional factor is a -number. These cases exhaust the possibilities, proving existence for every prime set. No unproved complement theorem or conjugacy theorem for Hall subgroups was inserted into the proof.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2014 ib Paper 1 10E Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-06
If with , a Sylow subgroup for is a subgroup of order . The Sylow theorems assert: such subgroups exist; every -subgroup is contained in a Sylow subgroup; all Sylow -subgroups are conjugate; and their number divides and satisfies .
For groups of order p squared q are not simple, if , then and force . Its unique Sylow subgroup is a nontrivial proper normal subgroup. Suppose instead . If either Sylow count is one, the conclusion already follows. Otherwise , while is either or . The value is impossible because . Thus , and . Primality and imply , hence . The only consecutive primes are .
In that exceptional order- case, four distinct Sylow -subgroups contribute eight distinct nonidentity elements: their intersections are trivial. Only three nonidentity elements remain. Every subgroup of order four must contain exactly those remaining three, so there can be only one Sylow -subgroup, contradicting the assumption that both counts were nontrivial. Therefore no group of order with distinct primes is simple.
For the final factorization, normality of ensures is a Sylow -subgroup of . By Sylow conjugacy within , choose such that . Then satisfiesThus and . We have proved the Frattini argumentThe normaliser factorization includes the case , when its normalizer is all of .