Even primitive groups of safe-prime degree Created 2026-10-14 Updated 2026-11-05
Every nontrivial normal subgroup of a faithful primitive group of prime degree is transitive and contains a Sylow -subgroup . Its normalizer in has order . For a proper normal subgroup , the Frattini argument gives ; unless , its -normalizer is the full order- normalizer, while . The Burnside transfer theorem gives a characteristic normal -complement in . This complement is normal in and cannot be transitive because its order is prime to , so it is trivial. Thus and .
Let in a finite group. If contains and is a nilpotent group, every Sylow subgroup of has . The Frattini argument gives , and the defining non-generator property of forces . Hence is a nilpotent group.
Hall subgroup existence in soluble groups Created 2026-10-07 Updated 2026-11-05
Every finite soluble group has a Hall subgroup for each prime set. Induct on the group order using an elementary abelian minimal normal subgroup. In the coprime hard case, lift a minimal normal subgroup of the quotient, choose its Sylow subgroup, and apply the Frattini argument. A proper normalizer reduces the order; a normal Sylow subgroup allows induction in its quotient. This proves existence without assuming an independent complement theorem.
Put and choose a Sylow subgroup of . Since is normal, the Frattini argument gives : for , the Sylow subgroups and of are conjugate by an element of , leaving an element of . The non-generator property of the Frattini subgroup proved above forces . Thus every Sylow subgroup of is normal. Distinct such Sylow subgroups commute because their group commutators lie in their trivial intersection. Hence is a nilpotent normal subgroup, and
Put and let be the full preimage of in . The preceding part gives , so the normal nilpotent image lies in .
For the reverse inclusion, choose a Sylow subgroup of . Its image is the unique Sylow subgroup of the nilpotent group , hence a characteristic subgroup there and normal in . Thus . The subgroup is also a Sylow subgroup of : the p-part of lies in , because is a Sylow subgroup of the normal subgroup of . Apply the Frattini argument to :
The Frattini subgroup property forces . Hence every Sylow subgroup of is normal, so is a nilpotent group and . Together the inclusions prove
This is Frattini lifting of nilpotence; simply calling an extension of nilpotent groups nilpotent would not establish it.
For of finite subgroup index, let and choose a right-coset transversal for the cosets . For each write
The transfer homomorphism is
The product is taken in the abelianization, so its order is irrelevant. If another transversal has representative for , with , its factor is . The map permutes , so the extra factors cancel in . This proves independence of the transversal. Also
Multiplying over and again permuting the second indices proves . Thus it is indeed a group homomorphism.
The Burnside transfer theorem states that if a Sylow -subgroup of a finite group satisfies , then has a normal -complement: a normal subgroup of order . The hypothesis first makes abelian. It also makes fusion inside trivial. To prove this, suppose and , using . Both and lie in : the former because is abelian, and the latter because . They are Sylow subgroups of that centralizer. Choose with . Then and , while the central-normalizer hypothesis gives . Thus .
Evaluate transfer to the abelian group on . In the action of on right cosets, a cycle of length contributes
with . This is a conjugate of inside and hence equals by the fusion argument. Summing the cycle lengths therefore gives
The exponent is coprime to , so this power map is an automorphism of the finite abelian -group . Transfer is consequently onto , and its kernel is normal of subgroup index and of order prime to . This proves the theorem. Notice also that a normal -complement consists exactly of the elements of prime-to- order: they map trivially to the -group quotient, while all elements of the complement have such order. It is therefore unique and a characteristic subgroup.
Now let be primitive of degree , with prime. Every nontrivial normal subgroup of a faithful primitive group action is transitive: its orbits form a -invariant block partition, and singleton orbits would make it trivial. Such a subgroup has order divisible by . A Sylow -subgroup has order , since contains only one factor . The normalizer of a regular -cycle in is the affine group on , of order . Translations are even, whereas a generating multiplier gives a -cycle and is odd. Its normalizer in therefore has order .
Suppose is not simple and choose proper. It is transitive, so we can choose . The Frattini argument gives : for each , the subgroup is a Sylow subgroup of and can be conjugated back to within . Since contains and lies in the order- normalizer, it has order or . If its order were , the Burnside theorem applied to would give a normal -complement. A nontrivial such complement cannot be transitive because its order is prime to , contradicting primitivity. It must be trivial, giving , contrary to the choice of . Thus .
The intersection again has order or . If it had order , the whole normalizer would lie in and the Frattini equality would give . Hence . Applying Burnside transfer within gives its normal -complement . By the uniqueness argument, is a characteristic subgroup of , and so normal in . Primitivity again forces this prime-to- subgroup to be trivial. Thus is normal in , and has order . The even primitive groups of safe-prime degree conclusion is
For a finite group, define the Frattini subgroup by
the intersection is when there are no maximal subgroups, which for a finite group happens only for . A second definition is the set of non-generators: an element such that always implies .
If and , put in a maximal subgroup . Then , so . Conversely, if , some maximal subgroup omits it; maximality gives , although . This proves equivalence.
Every group automorphism permutes maximal subgroups, so is a characteristic subgroup, in particular a normal subgroup. Also
a proper would lie in a maximal subgroup containing both factors.
Set and take a Sylow subgroup of . For , normality of makes a Sylow subgroup of . Conjugating inside therefore gives the Frattini argument factorization . The preceding generating property forces . Thus every Sylow subgroup of is normal, and part (i) shows that is a nilpotent group.
Now suppose is a finite p-group. The normalizer condition makes every maximal subgroup normal: and maximality force . The quotient has no proper nontrivial subgroup, hence is cyclic of prime order; its p-power order makes that prime . Consequently every such contains
where the two factors are the commutator subgroup and the subgroup generated by pth powers. Thus .
The quotient is an elementary abelian group, hence a vector space over . If , extend the nonzero vector to a basis and choose a linear functional nonzero on it. Its kernel pulls back to a subgroup of index , a maximal subgroup omitting . Therefore , proving
The two factors in the last formula are multiplied; the superscripted expression in the TeX aid is not the formula printed in the PDF.
We prove Hall subgroup existence in soluble groups by induction on . The trivial group is immediate. Choose a nontrivial minimal normal subgroup , elementary abelian of order by part (c). Induction gives a Hall -subgroup of ; let be its full preimage.
If , then itself is the required subgroup. If and , apply induction inside the soluble subgroup to obtain a Hall -subgroup of . Since and are both -numbers, is Hall in too.
It remains to treat and . Then is a -group. If , the subgroup one works. Otherwise choose a minimal normal subgroup of , an elementary abelian -group with . Let be a Sylow -subgroup of . As and , we have . The permitted Frattini argument gives
The last equality uses and the normality of .
If , then is a power of , hence a -number. Apply induction to and multiply indices as before. If , then is a nontrivial normal -subgroup. Induction in gives a Hall -subgroup whose full preimage in is Hall, since its additional factor is a -number. These cases exhaust the possibilities, proving existence for every prime set. No unproved complement theorem or conjugacy theorem for Hall subgroups was inserted into the proof.
If with , a Sylow subgroup for is a subgroup of order . The Sylow theorems assert: such subgroups exist; every -subgroup is contained in a Sylow subgroup; all Sylow -subgroups are conjugate; and their number divides and satisfies .
For groups of order p squared q are not simple, if , then and force . Its unique Sylow subgroup is a nontrivial proper normal subgroup. Suppose instead . If either Sylow count is one, the conclusion already follows. Otherwise , while is either or . The value is impossible because . Thus , and . Primality and imply , hence . The only consecutive primes are .
In that exceptional order- case, four distinct Sylow -subgroups contribute eight distinct nonidentity elements: their intersections are trivial. Only three nonidentity elements remain. Every subgroup of order four must contain exactly those remaining three, so there can be only one Sylow -subgroup, contradicting the assumption that both counts were nontrivial. Therefore no group of order with distinct primes is simple.
For the final factorization, normality of ensures is a Sylow -subgroup of . By Sylow conjugacy within , choose such that . Then satisfies
Thus and . We have proved the Frattini argument
The normaliser factorization includes the case , when its normalizer is all of .