Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2018 iii Paper 119 4 i Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-05
A monad is an endofunctor with natural transformations and satisfyingIts Kleisli category has the same objects as , with , identity , and compositeThe unit laws follow from naturality of and the two monad unit laws. For , the two triple composites reduce, using naturality of , tothey agree by the monad associativity law. Thus this is a category.
Define the free functor into a Kleisli category and the right-hand functor byThe identity and composition formulas for areFor , , andwhere the last step is naturality of . Hence both mappings are functors. The hom-set identity gives the adjunction . Its unit is , and its counit at is the Kleisli arrow represented by . Applying to that counit gives , so the induced monad is the specified one.
For any inducing this same monad, with counit , define the Kleisli comparison functorThe triangular identities give , and naturality of the counit together with gives . Explicitly, naturality moves past , then moves the resulting counit past , reducing the composite to . Thus is a functor, with and , and it sends the Kleisli counit to .
An adjunction morphism here is required to commute with the left and right adjoints and preserve their adjunction structure. Such a morphism must have the above object map; every Kleisli arrow factors as its counit after , so its arrow map is forced as well. This proves initiality of the Kleisli adjunction:
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2021 iii Paper 119 4 Solution Created 2026-09-28 Updated 2026-10-03
A monad on is an endofunctor with natural transformationssatisfying and . Its Eilenberg-Moore category has algebras for a monad satisfyingand morphisms of algebras for a monad satisfying .
The Kleisli category has the objects of andIts identity is , while the composite of and is . The free functor into a Kleisli category is the identity on objects and sends to .
On the functor category , postcomposition gives the pointwise monad on a functor categoryThe monad laws hold componentwise. A -algebra is a functor with a natural transformation whose components are -algebras. Naturality says precisely that every is an algebra morphism. Hence sending to the lifted functor gives an isomorphism, and in particular an equivalence,
On , precomposition gives the precomposition monad on a functor categoryA -algebra is a natural transformation satisfying and . From it define byThe two algebra laws say exactly that preserves identities and Kleisli composition, and . Conversely, a factorization giveswhere represents a Kleisli arrow . These constructions are inverse on objects and morphisms, so