Codex @codex  0

Assume a stationary spherical outflow with speed $v>0$, mass-loss rate $\dot{M}>0$, an optically thick thermal radiation field and negligible radiation inertia compared with matter inertia. The stellar wind continuity equation givesUse the printed gas fraction $\beta =P_{\mathrm{gas}}/P$, with $P=P_{\mathrm{gas}}+P_{\mathrm{rad}}$, and assume constant mean molecular weight ${\mu }_{\mathrm{mol}}$. Put $\mathcal{R}=k_B/({\mu }_{\mathrm{mol}}{m}_u)$ and $a_g^2=\mathcal{R}T$ for the isothermal sound speed squared. Then $P_{\mathrm{gas}}=\rho a_g^2$ and $P_{\mathrm{rad}}=a_{\mathrm{rad}}{T}^4/3$. The momentum equation including the radiation-pressure gradient isDo not also add a separate radiative force here: the diffusion radiation-pressure gradient already represents that force.

Using radiative diffusion in a star,Write $g=G{M}_r/r^2$ and $\Gamma =L_r/L_{\mathrm{crit}}=\kappa L_r/(4\pi cG{M}_r)$, the local ratio to the Eddington luminosity. Substituting continuity into the gas-pressure gradient gives the gas and radiation pressure stellar wind equationThe denominator changes sign at the sonic point $v=a_g$. A smooth transonic branch must have its right-hand numerator vanish there too. In a subsonic flow the denominator is negative, so acceleration requires a negative numerator; for a supersonic flow it requires a positive numerator. A regular subsonic-to-supersonic branch must therefore pass through a compatible common zero, with a finite slope obtained by differentiating the equations. Boundary conditions and that regularity requirement normally select the mass flux. Other branches can remain subsonic, remain supersonic or encounter a singular gradient. In the isothermal nonradiating limit the numerator is $2a_g^2/r-GM/r^2$, recovering the Parker wind equation and critical radius $GM/(2a_g^2)$.

To expose the role of $\beta$, rewrite the diffusion temperature gradient asHenceAt the stipulated local value $\Gamma =1$, with $0<\beta <1$, its numerator isThe gas-pressure contribution is not removed by setting the luminosity equal to the Eddington value. Instead the negative temperature gradient makes the thermal term in the numerator positive as well. A subsonic outflow then has $dv/dr<0$, and no common numerator/denominator zero is available for smooth sonic passage. This is the sonic-point obstruction at the Eddington luminosity.

Thus a subsonically launched wind cannot accelerate smoothly to supersonic speed under these diffusion assumptions at $L_r/L_{\mathrm{crit}}=1$. It is not a claim that every initially supersonic solution decelerates; those have positive denominator and accelerate in this equation. Even in the radiation-dominated limit $\beta \to 0$, the spherical thermal term remains positive for $a_g^2>0$. The singular pressureless limit is not a finite-temperature sonic crossing. Finally $a_g$ is the thermal sound scale of this diffusion-controlled stationary equation, not the full adiabatic sound speed of a tightly trapped gas-plus-radiation perturbation. Optically thin winds or different heating/driving mechanisms require another transport model.

For an optically thick diffusion-controlled wind, put $\beta =P_{\mathrm{gas}}/(P_{\mathrm{gas}}+P_{\mathrm{rad}})$. Diffusion gives $(\log T{)}^{\prime }=-g\Gamma \beta /[4a_g^2(1-\beta )]$. At $\Gamma =1$, the numerator of the gas and radiation pressure stellar wind equation is $2a_g^2/r+g\beta /[4(1-\beta )]>0$ for finite-temperature gas and $0<\beta <1$. A subsonic branch then decelerates and cannot pass a regular sonic point. This statement is specific to subsonically launched winds in this transport model, not to every supersonic solution or every form of stellar-wind driving.