Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2014 iii Paper 19 3 iii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
We give an explicit Gimel recursion for cardinal exponentiation. First recover the continuum function by induction on infinite cardinals. At a regular ,because . At a singular , put and , whose value is already known. A cofinal sequence givesIndeed , while gives the reverse inequality after raising to .
If the supremum is attained, the continuum function is eventually constant below , and we may choose with and . Then . If it is not attained, the increasing cofinal power values show . To verify the reverse cofinality bound, fewer than such lower power values have indices bounded below , and cannot be cofinal in ; the upper bound comes from . ConsequentlyEvery singular-stage value is therefore determined by the previously computed powers and the given Gimel function.
Now fix an infinite exponent and recurse on the infinite base . If , then , already known. For a successor base , every function has bounded range, and each bounded range has size at most . HenceThis is the Hausdorff formula for cardinal exponentiation. For a limit base , put and . If , all ranges are bounded and counting over those bounds gives (here ).
If , then . To see the nontrivial upper bound, use a cofinal sequence of bounds . A function is coded by the assignment of each argument to one of these bounds, together with padded functions into the corresponding bounds. The assignment has at most possibilities, and the functions have at most possibilities. Conversely and , giving the lower bound. If is attained as , then by currying; otherwise by the same cofinal-index argument as above. ThusOnly smaller-base powers occur in , so this is a genuine recursion, not an implicit appeal to the unknown power.
Finally, finite positive exponents give for infinite ; finite bases at infinite exponents satisfy for . The cases with base or , exponent , or both arguments finite are elementary, with under the empty-function convention. The Gimel function therefore determines both requested class functions completely.