On the smooth-function space, the product rule gives while . Hence , and both maps preserve the stated smooth space.
For general operators with this commutator relation, use . Induction gives for . Since ,
Every displayed vector lies in , so is invariant under , as well as under . Iterating the lowering formula gives for , and zero for .
Suppose a nontrivial finite linear dependence has highest nonzero term . Applying kills all lower terms and yields . The field is real, , and , so this contradicts . Thus the entire sequence is linearly independent. This identity commutator cyclic ladder also proves that such a representation with a nonzero vector in the kernel of cannot be finite dimensional.