First prove the exact lifting statement for the forgetful functor . Take any diagram in a category of algebras for a monad whose underlying diagram has a chosen categorical limit . The arrows form a categorical cone, since every diagram arrow is a morphism of algebras for a monad. Thus the universal property gives a unique arrow satisfying
The projections are jointly monic: two arrows into with the same composites with every are equal. Therefore the algebra identities can be checked after these projections. For the unit,
For multiplication,
The algebra law for makes the right-hand sides equal. Thus is an algebra for a monad, and each is a morphism of algebras for a monad. Its action is unique with this property.
Given an algebra cone , let be its unique underlying mediating map. Then
so by joint monicity. Hence is an algebra map, proving the lifted cone is limiting. This establishes that the monad algebra forgetful functor creates limits, without any assumption that preserves limits.
For a monadic adjunction, the comparison satisfies . If is an isomorphism of categories over the base, the preceding unique lift transports back literally, so is a limit-creating functor. If monadic means that is only an equivalence of categories, the precise conclusion is creation of limits up to isomorphism: the lifted algebra is isomorphic to an object , and its limiting cone transports along that isomorphism. Full faithfulness supplies the arrows and their uniqueness.
This distinction concerns prescribed underlying objects, not existence of limits. Literal creation does not follow from an arbitrary equivalence alone. For example, the inclusion of the one-object category into the two-object indiscrete category, choosing one of its objects, is an equivalence of categories and is monadic under the equivalence convention. Either object of the target is terminal, but the other chosen terminal object has no literal object preimage. Thus the strict reading of the requested assertion needs the strict comparison convention; the equivalence-invariant statement is proved above.
For a diagram , a limit-preserving functor carries every limiting cone over a diagram to a limiting categorical cone. A limit-reflecting functor has the converse property: a categorical cone is limiting whenever its image is limiting. A limit-creating functor uniquely lifts every specified limiting categorical cone over the image diagram to a categorical cone over , and the lift is limiting. These definitions concern diagrams of the stipulated shape; creation includes the lifting requirement, not merely reflection.
Let be a categorical limit of . The map
is a bijection: the right side consists exactly of compatible families of arrows from , and the categorical limit's universal property gives their unique factorization through . The bijection is induced by the categorical limit projections, so it proves that covariant representables preserve limits, including the empty diagram and its terminal object.
Construct pointwise limits in a functor category. For , choose at each object a categorical limit of , with projections . For , the family is compatible; define uniquely by
The universal property gives and , since those equalities hold after every projection. Thus is a functor, and each is a natural transformation.
For any categorical cone , the pointwise categorical limits give unique maps . To check naturality, compose and with every ; both become . The projections distinguish arrows into their categorical limit, so the two maps agree. Componentwise uniqueness gives uniqueness of the natural transformation . This proves that really is the required categorical limit, rather than merely a family of objectwise candidates.
A specified categorical limit categorical cone in fixes these objectwise vertices and projections. The displayed equation forces every arrow , and the argument forces every categorical cone factorization. Hence the forgetful functor uniquely lifts that categorical cone and is a limit-creating functor. The construction only takes small categorical limits in ; it does not require to be small. As usual, the functor categories are understood in a universe where their collections of transformations are meaningful.
For small diagrams with complete codomain, choose each objectwise categorical limit. For , its projections uniquely define the arrow through . The universal property proves identity and composition laws. The same projection calculation makes every categorical cone factorization a natural transformation. Hence these are genuine categorical limits in the functor category, and the objectwise forgetful functor is a limit-creating functor.