Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2009 iii Paper 69 6 c Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Take and . Since , every cosine term vanishes at , andSet and . For , the sine argument lies in , where . The initial part therefore has a common sign and magnitude at least . The remaining tail has absolute value at mostThe reverse triangle inequality now givesfor sufficiently large , because . This establishes the sharp logarithmic lower boundThe constant can be reduced to include the finitely many small indices: for the displayed lower bound is positive; for the first sine exceeds the tail bound , and for the first two sines contribute , exceeding the remaining tail bound . At the logarithmic right side is zero.
Here but is not Lipschitz continuous, so a first modulus of continuity bound is sufficient by the first Jackson theorem for periodic approximation but is not necessary. Nor is the weaker necessary bound sufficient: an explicit comparison is the logarithmic cusp with slow trigonometric approximationextended periodically. On it is increasing and concave, so its largest increment over distance is from zero, giving for .
For a concrete approximation lower bound, its cosine Fourier coefficients satisfyIndeed, integration by parts once replaces by ; integrating that against sine with primitive yields the stated positive integral. Its logarithmic growth follows because stays bounded by the Dirichlet test. All are negative and absolutely summable.
Let , a de la Vallée Poussin sum. Its multiplier is one for , for , and zero for ; the Fejér summation is a uniform-norm contraction property gives . Thus the functional has norm at most four and vanishes on every degree-at-most- trigonometric polynomial. Because the remaining multiplier weights are nonnegative and all ,The first Jackson theorem for periodic approximation gives the corresponding upper bound. The same first-modulus order occurs with both and . Therefore first-modulus rates alone do not characterize the endpoint approximation class, unlike the matched direct and inverse rates for .